| 100% | AJAR | 4 | The Blue ___ (Hank Azaria's "Mystery Men" role) |
| 52% | HANKAZARIA | 10 | Actor whose roles have included The Blue Raja in 1999 film comedy Mystery Men |
| 49% | MYERS | 5 | Mike —, actor who played the title role in films Wayne's World and Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery |
| 44% | ASTA | 4 | Skippy's role in The Thin Man |
| 43% | NORA | 4 | Myrna's role in the "Thin Man" movies |
| 42% | GROUP | 5 | Blue Man ___ (act that's performing at the Luxor in Las Vegas) |
| 42% | IRON | 4 | ___ Man (Robert Downey Jr.'s role in the upcoming "The Avengers") |
| 42% | ATHOS | 5 | Malkovich's role in "The Man in the Iron Mask" |
| 42% | GLOOMYGUS | 9 | Member of the blue man group? |
| 39% | MOON | 4 | "...little boy blue and the man on the ___..." ("Cat's in the Cradle" lyrics) |
| 38% | CRAWFORD | 8 | Broderick —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar winner for All the King’s Men |
| 38% | MCCOY | 5 | Hank ___ (real name of the X-Men's Beast) |
| 38% | NORA | 4 | Myrna's role in "The Thin Man" |
| 38% | TEMPLAR | 7 | Charteris's mystery man, Simon ___ |
| 37% | NORA | 4 | Myrna's role in "The Thin Man" movies |
| 36% | ARAMIS | 6 | "The Man in the Iron Mask" role for Jeremy Irons |
| 36% | CARR | 4 | John Dickson —, author of 1935 mystery The Hollow Man |
| 36% | LARRY | 5 | 2011 romcom starring Tom Hanks in the title role |
| 36% | STORM | 5 | Halle Berry's role in the X-Men movies |
| 36% | BEAST | 5 | Kelsey Grammer's role in the "X-Men" films |
| 36% | HOPE | 4 | Evangeline Lilly's role in the "Ant-Man" films |
| 36% | NED | 3 | Jacob Batalon's role in the Spider-Man movies |
| 36% | LIME | 4 | Welles's "The Third Man" role |
| 36% | CARR | 4 | John Dickson —, author of 1935 mystery novel The Hollow Man |
| 36% | CHARLIE | 7 | & 25A 2007 biopic starring Tom Hanks in the title role |
| 36% | BEAST | 5 | Kelsey Grammer's role in "X-Men: The Last Stand" |
| 36% | ZEPPO | 5 | Marx brother who typically had the role of straight man |