| 100% | CAYMAN | 6 | The Caribbean's ___ Islands |
| 88% | CURACAO | 7 | One of the Caribbean's ABC Islands |
| 85% | ARUBA | 5 | One of the Caribbean’s A.B.C. islands |
| 78% | ARUBA | 5 | The A in the Caribbean's ABC islands |
| 77% | ARUBA | 5 | The "A" of the Caribbean's "ABC Islands" |
| 77% | HAITI | 5 | Caribbean country that's part of the island of Hispaniola |
| 75% | GRENADA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean, capital is St. George's |
| 74% | CURACAO | 7 | Blue Caribbean liqueur or the island it's made on |
| 72% | ARUBA | 5 | Caribbean island that's the first word of the 1988 Beach Boys hit "Kokomo" |
| 72% | STLUCIA | 7 | Caribbean island with the Pitons |
| 69% | HAITI | 5 | Caribbean country sharing the island of Hispaniola |
| 69% | BARBADOS | 8 | Caribbean island considered the birthplace of rum |
| 69% | JAMAICA | 7 | Caribbean island country with the capital Kingston |
| 69% | CUBA | 4 | Caribbean island where the mambo was born |
| 69% | ANTIGUA | 7 | Caribbean island from the Spanish for "ancient" |
| 69% | SAINTVINCENT | 12 | Caribbean island called Yurumein by the Garifuna |
| 69% | CAYMAN | 6 | Caribbean's — Islands |
| 69% | CAYMAN | 6 | Caribbean's ___ Islands |
| 68% | GRENADA | 7 | Island country in the Caribbean Sea whose capital is St George’s |
| 68% | BONAIRE | 7 | The B of the Dutch ABC Caribbean islands |
| 68% | GRENADA | 7 | Caribbean island invaded by the USA in 1983 |
| 68% | TOBAGO | 6 | The twin Caribbean island state of Trinidad and __ |
| 68% | ARUBA | 5 | Caribbean locale with the slogan "One Happy Island" |
| 68% | HAITI | 5 | Caribbean country on the west of Hispaniola island |
| 67% | JAMAICA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean; capital Kingston |
| 67% | HAVANA | 6 | The Caribbean’s “City of Columns” |
| 66% | GRENADA | 7 | Caribbean island country invaded by the US in 1983 |
| 66% | ARUBA | 5 | Island getaway in the Caribbean |
| 65% | ARUBA | 5 | Caribbean island with the same final three letters as another |
| 65% | ANTIGUA | 7 | Island in the Caribbean linked administratively with Barbuda |