| 100% | ERIK | 4 | The name of the phantom in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 78% | ERIK | 4 | The Phantom in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 74% | GIRY | 4 | Madame __, concierge in The Phantom of the Opera |
| 73% | DAAE | 4 | Christine who's the protagonist in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 73% | ERIK | 4 | The phantom's name in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 72% | RAOUL | 5 | Phantom's rival, in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 71% | RAOUL | 5 | Vicomte in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 71% | ERIK | 4 | Leading role in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 70% | RAOUL | 5 | Suitor of Christine in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 70% | ERIK | 4 | Christine's lover in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 70% | LON | 3 | Chaney who starred in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 70% | MUSICALCHORES | 13 | Polishing the chandelier in "The Phantom of the Opera" and laundering uniforms in "Hamilton"? |
| 69% | ERIK | 4 | First name of the Phantom of the Opera |
| 68% | LON | 3 | ___ Chaney, silent movie star who acted in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 68% | LON | 3 | Chaney who starred in "The Phantom of the Opera" (not Webber's) |
| 66% | ERIK | 4 | The Phantom of the Opera's name |
| 65% | ERIK | 4 | The Phantom of the Opera's first name |
| 63% | ERIK | 4 | The Phantom of "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 63% | AIDA | 4 | "Celeste ___" (aria whose title includes the name of the opera it's in) |
| 63% | ERIK | 4 | The Phantom of the Opera's name, almost similar to 2d |
| 62% | GANDALF | 7 | The name of the wizard in The Hobbit |
| 61% | PUMBAA | 6 | The name of the warthog in The Lion King |
| 61% | ERIK | 4 | First name of the title character of "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 61% | RAOUL | 5 | The Phantom's rival, in "The Phantom of the Opera" |
| 60% | TOMCANTY | 8 | Name of the pauper in The Prince and the Pauper |
| 60% | MAJESTIC | 8 | ___ Theater, venue of "The Phantom of the Opera," the longest-running production in Broadway history |
| 59% | MAHARAJA | 8 | Name of the leader in the Indian Empire |
| 59% | BUTTERCUP | 9 | Name of the princess in The Princess Bride |
| 59% | GHOSTFACE | 9 | Name of the killer in the Scream series |
| 59% | ERIK | 4 | Phantom of the Opera |