| 100% | DEANS | 5 | They make lists of those who are good |
| 50% | DEATHMASK | 9 | Made by Mme Tussaud of those who were guillotined |
| 46% | SMART | 5 | "A ___ cookie," idiom referring to someone who is clever and capable of making good decisions |
| 46% | SCHINDLER | 9 | Surname of a man who made a list that saved people |
| 46% | GALILEO | 7 | Astronomer who was the first to discover that the Milky Way was made up of stars |
| 45% | SCENES | 6 | People who are apoplectic don't really care if they make a few of these or not |
| 44% | MINORS | 6 | Those who are below the age of consent |
| 44% | ATE | 3 | Ancient Greek goddess who makes men blind so that they will blunder into guilty acts |
| 43% | NURSE | 5 | What Barbie becomes when she takes care of those who are ill |
| 43% | STOWE | 5 | Who wrote in an 1852 novel “Any mind that is capable of a real sorrow is capable of good” |
| 42% | REALISTS | 8 | Those who see things how they are |
| 42% | COAL | 4 | What Santa brings those who are on the naughty list |
| 41% | WALTERCHRYSLER | 14 | American industrialist who founded the company that made cars like the PT Cruiser, and is now a partner of Fiat |
| 41% | TIMETABLE | 9 | List of activities and the times they'll be done |
| 40% | CAMBRIDGE | 9 | William who was made Duke of __ in 2011 |
| 40% | MUSTACHES | 9 | They may be made of milk |
| 40% | SONDHEIM | 8 | Composer who wrote, about crosswords, "A good clue can give you all the pleasures of being duped that a mystery story can" |
| 40% | ERRATA | 6 | List of book goofs that may be fixed in second issues |
| 40% | MENU | 4 | List of choices that may be in chalk, at a diner |
| 40% | ETC | 3 | Abbr. for those who didn't make the list |
| 40% | PARANOID | 8 | Like those who think this clue is about them |
| 40% | RIHANNA | 7 | Singer from Barbados who was part of the 2012 "Time 100" list of most influential people and is one of the best-selling artists of all time |
| 40% | ABS | 3 | They might be made of steel, hyperbolically |
| 40% | ATOMS | 5 | Molecules are made of them |
| 39% | STREISAND | 9 | Broadway star who was on Nixon's list of enemies |
| 39% | PIANOKEYS | 9 | They were traditionally made of ebony and ivory |
| 39% | DAYS | 4 | "... those were the best ___ of my life..." |
| 39% | OLLAS | 5 | Jars that are made of clay |
| 39% | NICE | 4 | (2/6) "Well kids, it's that time of year again--let's check the list! Who's been naughty, and who's been ___?" |
| 39% | IONS | 4 | Table salt is made of them |