| 100% | MILT | 4 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Pappas |
| 84% | NEN | 3 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Robb |
| 84% | SOTO | 4 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Mario |
| 84% | LARY | 4 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Frank |
| 84% | NEN | 3 | Three-time All-Star pitcher Robb ___ |
| 80% | NEN | 3 | Three-time All-Star relief pitcher Robb |
| 66% | CATOSTERMAN | 11 | All-star softball pitcher with three Olympic medals |
| 63% | OMAR | 4 | Three-time All-Star shortstop Vizquel |
| 63% | CHET | 4 | Three-time All-Star outfielder Lemon |
| 63% | GRADY | 5 | Three-time All-Star fielder Sizemore |
| 62% | TODDHELTON | 10 | Five-time All Star, four-time Silver Slugger, and three-time Golden glove winner |
| 61% | STIEB | 5 | Seven-time All-Star pitcher Dave |
| 61% | SALE | 4 | Six-time All-Star pitcher Chris |
| 61% | SALE | 4 | Seven-time All-Star pitcher Chris |
| 59% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time All-Star Longoria for the Tampa Bay Rays |
| 59% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time baseball All-Star Longoria |
| 59% | ILYA | 4 | Three-time NHL All-Star Kovalchuk |
| 59% | BEN | 3 | Three-time NBA All-Star Simmons |
| 59% | MARC | 4 | Three-time NBA All-Star Gasol |
| 59% | EVAN | 4 | Three-time MLB All-Star Longoria |
| 58% | ONEAL | 5 | Three-time NBA All-Star Game MVP |
| 57% | STIEB | 5 | Dave ___, seven-time All-Star pitcher for the Blue Jays |
| 56% | ILYA | 4 | Three-time N.H.L. All-Star Kovalchuk |
| 56% | DERON | 5 | Three-time N.B.A. All-Star Williams |
| 56% | GUYS | 4 | When said three times, "Come on, you all" |
| 55% | BOBBYBONDS | 10 | Three-time All-Star outfielder whose son was a seven-time N.L. MVP |
| 55% | SOTO | 4 | Three-time All-Star slugger Juan who was traded to the Yankees in 2023 |
| 55% | ACE | 3 | All-Star pitcher |
| 54% | LUIS | 4 | All-Star pitcher Severino |
| 54% | LYLE | 4 | All-Star pitcher Sparky |