| 100% | MAIER | 5 | Three-time skiing world champion Hermann |
| 73% | MAHRE | 5 | Three-time World Cup skiing champion |
| 58% | PELE | 4 | Three-time World Cup champion |
| 57% | LENNOX | 6 | Three-time world heavyweight champion Lewis |
| 56% | JON | 3 | Three-time World Series champion pitcher ___ Lester |
| 56% | LAUDA | 5 | Three-time Formula One World Drivers' Champion Niki __ |
| 56% | STU | 3 | Three-time World Series of Poker champion Ungar |
| 54% | TESSA | 5 | ___ Virtue, three-time world ice dancing champion |
| 50% | LINDSEY | 7 | Vonn, four-time overall World Cup ski champion |
| 49% | VONN | 4 | World Cup skiing champion Lindsey |
| 47% | BRAVES | 6 | World Series champions in three different cities |
| 45% | PELE | 4 | Player on three World Cup champion teams |
| 45% | TED | 3 | ___ Ligety, American alpine ski racer who is a five-time World Cup champion in giant slalom |
| 44% | ROGERMARIS | 10 | Three-time World Series champion who broke Babe Ruth's single-season home run record on October 1, 1961 (2 wds.) |
| 44% | PELE | 4 | Player on three FIFA World Cup champion teams |
| 44% | TONI | 4 | Three-time skiing gold medalist Sailer |
| 44% | TONI | 4 | Three-time skiing gold medalist ___ Sailer |
| 43% | HALMICH | 7 | Regina ___, German boxer who was the WIBF's world champion in three divisions |
| 43% | PELE | 4 | One-named player on three World Cup champion teams |
| 43% | SUE | 3 | Three-time WNBA champion Bird |
| 43% | PELE | 4 | Three-time World Cup medalist |
| 43% | ITALY | 5 | Three-time World Cup winner |
| 43% | PELE | 4 | Three-time World Cup star |
| 42% | SEVEN | 5 | Number of times Babe Ruth became the World Series champion |
| 42% | LEMOND | 6 | Three-time Tour de France champion |
| 42% | LENDL | 5 | Three-time U.S. Open champion |
| 42% | THEAS | 5 | Three-time '70s World Series champs |
| 42% | ARANTXASANCHEZVICARIO | 21 | Three-time French Open champion |
| 42% | MCENROE | 7 | Three-time Wimbledon singles champion |
| 42% | SELES | 5 | Three-time French Open champion |