| 100% | FAIRIES | 7 | Tiny, mythical flying creatures of folklore |
| 49% | ELF | 3 | Diminutive creature of folklore |
| 49% | PIXIE | 5 | Impish creature of folklore |
| 48% | ELF | 3 | Pointy-eared creature of folklore |
| 47% | YETI | 4 | Creature of Sherpa folklore |
| 47% | GOLEM | 5 | Creature of Jewish folklore |
| 46% | PEGASUS | 7 | Mythical flying horse, son of Poseidon |
| 46% | GOLEM | 5 | Mud-made creature of Jewish folklore |
| 46% | GOLEM | 5 | 64-Across creature of Jewish folklore |
| 45% | GOLEM | 5 | Clay creature of Jewish folklore |
| 43% | YETI | 4 | Mythical creature of the Himalayas |
| 43% | NESSIE | 6 | Mythical creature of Scotland, familiarly |
| 42% | YETI | 4 | Mythical creature of Nepal and Tibet |
| 42% | CHUPACABRA | 10 | Mythical creature of Latin American lore |
| 41% | DRAGON | 6 | Mythical creature shown on the flag of Bhutan |
| 41% | ELEMENTAL | 9 | Mythical creature of earth, air, fire, or water |
| 41% | ANTEATER | 8 | Creature whose tongue has thousands of tiny hooks |
| 40% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical creature that's a national symbol of Scotland |
| 39% | SPHINX | 6 | Mythical creature: head of a human, body of a lion |
| 39% | UNICORN | 7 | Mythical horned creature that’s the national animal of Scotland |
| 39% | GNAT | 4 | Tiny pest that can fly inside a "cloud" of bugs |
| 38% | IMMORTAL | 8 | Quality of a mythical creature who can never die |
| 38% | COCKATRICE | 10 | Mythical creature; a two-legged dragon with the head of a cockerel |
| 37% | KELPIE | 6 | Australian breed of sheepdog named after a creature from Celtic folklore |
| 37% | YETI | 4 | Cooler brand whose name is also that of a mythical creature |
| 36% | HARPY | 5 | Mythical creature with the face of a woman and the body of a bird |
| 35% | BIRDS | 5 | Flying creatures |
| 35% | BIRD | 4 | Flying creature |
| 35% | ICARUS | 6 | Mythical flier |
| 35% | ROC | 3 | Mythical flier |