| 100% | KITTENS | 7 | Tiny pets that play with toy mice |
| 70% | CAT | 3 | Pet that might play with a toy mouse |
| 49% | PAWAT | 5 | Play with, as a toy mouse |
| 49% | PAWED | 5 | Played with a toy mouse, say |
| 49% | PAWED | 5 | Played with, as a toy mouse |
| 47% | PAWAT | 5 | Play with, as a cat might a toy mouse |
| 45% | YOYOING | 7 | Playing with a toy that goes up and down on string |
| 39% | VIBISTS | 7 | Musicians that play with mallets |
| 39% | DOGPARK | 7 | Place to play with toys |
| 39% | DINO | 4 | Animal that played with Pebbles Flintstone |
| 39% | CHILD | 5 | One who plays with toys, often |
| 39% | CAT | 3 | Pet that chases mice |
| 38% | ORCAS | 5 | Sea predators that play with their food |
| 38% | CATS | 4 | Pets who play with yarn |
| 38% | CAT | 3 | Pet that might catch mice |
| 38% | DOG | 3 | Pet that might play fetch |
| 38% | CAT | 3 | Pet that scares a mouse |
| 37% | NHL | 3 | Pro sports group that plays with sticks: Abbr. |
| 37% | DOGSIT | 6 | Play with someone else's toy? |
| 37% | LAPDOGS | 7 | Pets that do well with sitters? |
| 37% | PAWAT | 5 | Play with, as a catnip mouse |
| 37% | PUN | 3 | Joke that plays with different meanings of a word |
| 37% | CAT | 3 | Pet that might enjoy a rubber mouse |
| 36% | UNPACKANIMALS | 13 | Pets that help with luggage after a trip? |
| 36% | HAMSTER | 7 | Pet that might play on an exercise wheel |
| 36% | PAWSAT | 6 | Plays with, as a cat does a toy |
| 36% | LAPCAT | 6 | Pet that should come with a lint roller? |
| 36% | TAD | 3 | Tiny word that rhymes with "fad" |
| 36% | CHRISTMAS | 9 | Day to play with new toys |
| 36% | TUB | 3 | Where to play with bath toys |