| 100% | CYRANO | 6 | Title role for which Christopher Plummer won a Tony in 1974 |
| 56% | BESS | 4 | Title role for which Audra McDonald won a 2012 Tony Award |
| 47% | EVITA | 5 | Title role for which Patti LuPone won her first Tony |
| 47% | AUNTIEMAME | 10 | Play for which Peggy Cass won a Tony in 1957 |
| 46% | ALEX | 4 | Newell who won a Tony for their role in “Shucked” |
| 44% | ALEXNEWELL | 10 | Actor who won a Tony in 2023 for their role as Lulu in the Broadway musical "Shucked": 2 wds. |
| 43% | OSKAR | 5 | Title role in a 1993 film ... which sounds like a prize the film won |
| 41% | CYRANO | 6 | Christopher Plummer's Tony-winning title role of 1973 |
| 41% | ALISTROKER | 10 | Actress who won a Tony for her role as Ado Annie in the 2019 Broadway revival of "Oklahoma!": 2 wds. |
| 41% | HEIRESS | 7 | The —, 1949 film drama for which Olivia de Havilland won Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 41% | JEZEBEL | 7 | 1938 drama for which Bette Davis won a Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 41% | THECHAMP | 8 | 1931 film for which Wallace Beery won a Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 41% | SHINE | 5 | 1996 biopic for which Geoffrey Rush won a Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 40% | CISCOKID | 8 | Role for which Warner Baxter won a 1930 Oscar |
| 40% | STARSKY | 7 | Title role for Stiller in a 2004 comedy |
| 40% | BARNUM | 6 | Show for which Jim Dale won the 1980 Tony for Best Actor in a Musical |
| 40% | PIAF | 4 | Role for which Marion Cotillard won a 2007 Best Actress Oscar |
| 39% | TRUMBO | 6 | Title role for Bryan Cranston in a 2015 biopic |
| 39% | ALFIE | 5 | Title role for Jude Law in a 2004 remake |
| 39% | BOYSTOWN | 8 | 1938 film drama for which Spencer Tracy won a Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 39% | JEZEBEL | 7 | 1938 film drama for which Bette Davis won a Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 39% | KLUTE | 5 | 1971 film thriller for which Jane Fonda won a Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 39% | ROMANHOLIDAY | 12 | 1953 romcom for which Audrey Hepburn won Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscar |
| 39% | RAY | 3 | Title role for which Jamie Foxx won an Oscar for Best Actor |
| 39% | COMINGHOME | 10 | 1978 film drama for which Jon Voight and Jane Fonda won Best Actor and Best Actress in a Leading Role Oscars |
| 39% | NOAH | 4 | Title role for Russell Crowe in a 2014 biblical epic |
| 39% | ESTER | 5 | Title role for Rowin Amone in a 2019 web series |
| 39% | MULAN | 5 | Title role for Yifei Liu in a 2020 Disney film |
| 39% | SHANE | 5 | Title role for Alan Ladd in a classic 1953 western |