| 100% | DADDY | 5 | To whom "my heart belongs," in song |
| 70% | DADDY | 5 | To whom "my heart belongs" |
| 67% | DADDY | 5 | Whom "my heart belongs to" |
| 55% | ADELINE | 7 | "The flower of my heart" in song |
| 53% | ILOST | 5 | "___ my heart to her" (fell in love): 2 wds. |
| 53% | ADELINE | 7 | "The flower of my heart," in old song |
| 52% | DADDY | 5 | "My Heart Belongs to ___" |
| 52% | DADDY | 5 | "My Heart Belongs to __" |
| 52% | ONEI | 4 | "The ___ Gave My Heart To" (1997 Aaliyah song): 2 wds. |
| 50% | TEAR | 4 | "___ in My Heart" (Twenty One Pilots song) |
| 50% | OWNS | 4 | "Who ___ My Heart" (Miley Cyrus song) |
| 49% | DADDY | 5 | Ella Fitzgerald’s “My Heart Belongs to ___” |
| 48% | ETERNAL | 7 | "___ life belongs to those who live in the present": Wittgenstein |
| 48% | TONYBENNETT | 11 | "I Left My Heart in San Francisco" singer who's an accomplished painter: 2 wds. |
| 47% | HANDYMAN | 8 | Guy to see "if your broken heart needs repair," in a song |
| 46% | DYLAN | 5 | Bob ___, singer who covered the song "Take a Message to Mary" in 1970 |
| 45% | ANANG | 5 | Character who’s told “hear my words” in a They Might Be Giants song |
| 45% | SARA | 4 | "The poet in my heart," in a Fleetwood Mac song |
| 45% | SARA | 4 | "The poet in my heart," per a Fleetwood Mac song |
| 45% | TONYBENNETT | 11 | "I Left My Heart in San Francisco" singer honored with the 2017 Gershwin Prize for Popular Song (2 wds.) |
| 45% | BRODIE | 6 | Literary protagonist Jean who tells her pupils, “I am dedicated to you in my prime” |
| 44% | KICKSTART | 9 | "___ My Heart," song from Motley Crue's fifth album that also features in their biographical film |
| 44% | HELLO | 5 | Adele song with the lyric "I'm in California dreaming about who we used to be" |
| 44% | HESPERIDES | 10 | Daughters of evening in Greek mythology who guarded a tree bearing golden apples belonging to Hera |
| 43% | PIANOMAN | 8 | Person who was asked to "sing us a song tonight" in a Billy Joel hit: 2 wds. |
| 43% | ILEFT | 5 | "___ My Heart in San Francisco" |
| 43% | ILEFT | 5 | "— My Heart in San Francisco" |
| 43% | ILEFT | 5 | “— My Heart in San Francisco” |
| 43% | ILEFT | 5 | “___ My Heart in San Francisco” |
| 42% | MARGE | 5 | "The Simpsons" character who counsels, "You should listen to your heart, and not the voices in your head" |