| 100% | EQUUS | 5 | Tony-winning play of 1975 |
| 74% | THERITZ | 7 | Play for which 59-Across won a Tony, 1975 |
| 69% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony-winning play about a stableboy |
| 68% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony-winning play with a Latin name |
| 64% | MARY | 4 | ___ Martin, first Broadway actress to win a Tony Award for playing someone of the opposite sex |
| 64% | ANGELSINAMERICA | 15 | Tony Kushner play of 1993 |
| 63% | STEPHENDALDRY | 13 | "The Inheritance" director who won the 2020 Tony Award for Best Direction of a Play (2 wds.) |
| 63% | UTA | 3 | Tony-winning Hagen, who played Martha in "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?" |
| 62% | SAMMENDES | 9 | "The Ferryman" director who won the Tony Award for Best Direction of a Play in 2019 (2 wds.) |
| 62% | SALESMAN | 8 | "Death of a ___," first ever play to win a Tony Award for Best Production in four different years |
| 62% | OSLO | 4 | 2017 Tony-winning play whose title is also the name of Norway's capital |
| 62% | OSLO | 4 | 2017 Tony-winning play whose title is also the name of a Norwegian city |
| 62% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony-winning Peter Shaffer play whose 2007 revival starred Daniel Radcliffe |
| 60% | ELIOT | 5 | Writer of the 1950 Tony-winning play "The Cocktail Party" |
| 60% | HUMMEL | 6 | "The Basic Training of Pavlo ___," 1977 play starring Al Pacino for which he won a Tony Award for Best Actor |
| 59% | JEREMYSTRONG | 12 | "Succession" actor who won the 2024 Best Leading Actor in a Play Tony for "An Enemy of the People": 2 wds. |
| 59% | EQUUS | 5 | 1975 Tony winner for Best Play |
| 58% | OSLO | 4 | Tony-nominated play of 2017 |
| 57% | CLUTCH | 6 | Like a winning play in the final seconds of overtime |
| 55% | TRU | 3 | Play whose star won the 1990 Best Actor Tony |
| 55% | SAMETIMENEXTYEAR | 16 | 1975 Tony-nominated play about an extended affair |
| 55% | ATENOR | 6 | Tony-winning play, Lend Me ___ |
| 55% | PICNIC | 6 | Pulitzer-winning play of 1953 |
| 54% | AUNTIEMAME | 10 | Play for which Peggy Cass won a Tony in 1957 |
| 54% | TRU | 3 | Play for which Robert Morse won a Best Actor Tony |
| 54% | DAVEEDDIGGS | 11 | Tony Award-winning actor who plays Marquis de Lafayette/Thomas Jefferson in the film version of "Hamilton" (2 wds.) |
| 54% | SHALHOUB | 8 | Actor Tony who plays the father of 48-Across on an Emmy-winning Amazon series |
| 54% | FENCES | 6 | 1987 Tony-winning play |
| 54% | ONBROADWAY | 10 | Like Tony-winning plays |
| 53% | OSLO | 4 | Tony-winning play about 1990s peace accords |