| 100% | ALPACINO | 8 | Tony winner for "Does a Tiger Wear a Necktie?" |
| 45% | EZIOPINZA | 9 | 1950 Tony winner for Best Actor in a Musical |
| 45% | OKLAHOMA | 8 | 2019 Tony winner for Best Revival of a Musical |
| 45% | PARADE | 6 | 2023 Tony winner for Best Revival of a Musical |
| 43% | JACKLEMMON | 10 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar winner for Save the Tiger |
| 43% | SANDYSINNED | 11 | Two-time Tony winner did a no-no |
| 43% | LEMMON | 6 | Jack —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar winner for Save the Tiger |
| 42% | SANDYDENNIS | 11 | Tony winner for "A Thousand Clowns," 1963 |
| 42% | JANETMCTEER | 11 | Tony winner for "A Doll's House" |
| 41% | KEVINKLINE | 10 | 1981 Tony winner for "The Pirates of Penzance" (Best Leading Actor in a Musical): 2 wds. |
| 41% | RIGG | 4 | Diana —, 1994 Best Actress in a Play Tony Award winner for Medea |
| 41% | LAPOTAIRE | 9 | Jane —, 1981 Tony Award Best Actress in a Play winner for Piaf |
| 41% | NATHANLANE | 10 | 2001 Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award winner for The Producers |
| 40% | GOULET | 6 | Robert —, 1968 Best Actor in a Musical Tony Award winner for The Happy Time |
| 39% | JOHNS | 5 | Glynis —, 1973 Best Actress in a Musical Tony Award winner for A Little Night Music |
| 39% | DELATOUR | 8 | Frances —, 2006 Tony Award Best Featured Actress in a Play winner for The History Boys |
| 39% | BRODERICK | 9 | Matthew —, 1983 Best Featured Actor in a Play Tony Award winner for Brighton Beach Memoirs |
| 39% | HODGE | 5 | Douglas —, 2010 Tony Award Best Actor in a Musical winner for La Cage aux Folles |
| 39% | VEREEN | 6 | Tony winner for "Pippin" |
| 39% | TYNEDALY | 8 | Tony winner for "Gypsy" |
| 38% | SALONGA | 7 | Tony winner for “Miss Saigon” |
| 38% | CAROLCHANNING | 13 | Tony winner for "Hello, Dolly!" |
| 38% | DALY | 4 | Tyne —, 1990 Tony Award for Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical winner for Gypsy |
| 38% | ALANARKIN | 9 | Tony winner for "Enter Laughing," 1963 |
| 38% | CARIOU | 6 | Tony winner for "Sweeney Todd," 1979 |
| 38% | ODOM | 4 | Tony winner for "Hamilton," Leslie ____ Jr. |
| 37% | TEALE | 5 | Owen —, Welsh actor; 1997 Best Featured Actor in a Play Tony Award winner for A Doll's House |
| 37% | ALDA | 4 | Tony winner for "Guys and Dolls," 1951 |
| 37% | ZEROMOSTEL | 10 | Tony winner for "Fiddler on the Roof" |
| 37% | DUB | 3 | Do a voiceover for a character, say |