| 100% | ACELA | 5 | Train that stops in New Haven and New York |
| 57% | PIZZA | 5 | Food that New Haven and New York are noted for |
| 55% | HACKENSACK | 10 | River in New Jersey and New York, US, that flows into Newark Bay |
| 50% | METS | 4 | New York team that won the World Series in 1969 and 1986 |
| 50% | HOFSTRA | 7 | New York university that hosted presidential debates in 2008, 2012 and 2016 |
| 50% | CSI | 3 | Franchise that had locations in Miami, New York, and Vegas |
| 49% | GIANTS | 6 | San Francisco ___, Major League Baseball team that was founded in New York and relocated in 1958 |
| 46% | WILL | 4 | "___ & Grace," TV show starring Will Truman and Grace Adler that is set in New York City |
| 46% | BROAD | 5 | "___ City," TV show starring Abbi Jacobson and Ilana Glazer that is set in New York City |
| 46% | BICOASTAL | 9 | Having homes in Los Angeles and New York |
| 44% | ORANGE | 6 | County name in California, Florida and New York |
| 44% | ERIE | 4 | County name in Ohio, Pennsylvania and New York |
| 44% | SOHOS | 5 | Neighborhoods in New York and London |
| 44% | TEAMS | 5 | Giants in California and New York |
| 44% | ERIE | 4 | Lake that borders Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New York |
| 43% | TROYS | 5 | Classical-sounding cities in New York and Michigan |
| 43% | STJOHNS | 7 | University with campuses in New York and Rome |
| 43% | NEEDLE | 6 | Cleopatra's __, obelisks in New York and London |
| 43% | MAISON | 6 | __ Ladurée, macaron house in Paris and New York |
| 43% | BICOASTAL | 9 | Having homes in California and New York, say |
| 43% | PIZZA | 5 | It comes in California and New York styles |
| 43% | RENT | 4 | High cost in New York and San Francisco |
| 43% | ERIE | 4 | Great Lake that borders Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New York |
| 43% | SYRACUSE | 8 | Sicily city that names a city in New York |
| 43% | BAGELS | 6 | Dense bread rings that are popular in New York |
| 43% | ERIE | 4 | New York canal that opened in 1825 |
| 43% | ERIE | 4 | New York canal that opened in 1821 |
| 43% | ERIE | 4 | New York and ___ Railroad, started in 1832 |
| 42% | SNL | 3 | New York sketch-comedy show that premièred in 1975 (and is still on the air), briefly |