| 100% | DOTE | 4 | Treat with grandmotherly love, with "on" |
| 57% | OREO | 4 | Treat with its name on both sides |
| 56% | OREO | 4 | ___ Cone (Good Humor treat with crumbled cookie pieces on top) |
| 56% | BANANASPLIT | 11 | Fountain treat with cherries on top |
| 55% | DOTE | 4 | __ on; shower with love |
| 55% | DOTE | 4 | ___ on (shower with love) |
| 54% | REO | 3 | ___ Speedwagon with the hit "Keep On Loving You" |
| 54% | DOTE | 4 | ___ on (pamper with loving attention) |
| 53% | SNUGGLE | 7 | On a cozy indoor day, curl up with your loved one |
| 51% | ARTOODETOO | 10 | He fell in love with a fire hydrant on "Sesame Street" |
| 50% | BONNIE | 6 | __ Raitt, duetted on Love Letters with Elton John |
| 49% | GOSOFT | 6 | Treat leniently, with "on" |
| 49% | GOESEASY | 8 | Treats gently, with "on" |
| 49% | DOTE | 4 | Love excessively, with "on" |
| 49% | DOTES | 5 | Loves excessively, with "on" |
| 49% | COOKIE | 6 | ___ Monster, hungry blue monster with a love for sweet treats from "Sesame Street" |
| 48% | DOTE | 4 | Love to excess, with "on" |
| 48% | DOTE | 4 | Love to excess, with “on” |
| 48% | BERNIE | 6 | With 38-Across, he played Adam "Doc" Bricker on "The Love Boat" |
| 47% | HER | 3 | 2013 movie about a man who falls in love with the voice on his smartphone |
| 47% | ITINA | 5 | Book that "What's Love Got to Do With It" was based on |
| 47% | REBA | 4 | Country singer McEntire with the hit "I Keep On Loving You" |
| 46% | DONALD | 6 | With 38-Across, "Scrubs" actor who plays Trey, Julia's new love interest, on 15-Across |
| 46% | PEABO | 5 | Bryson who duetted with Roberta Flack on “Tonight, I Celebrate My Love” |
| 45% | CARLOS | 6 | ___ Santana, Mexican-American guitarist who collaborated with John McLaughlin on "A Love Supreme" |
| 44% | REUBEN | 6 | Treat with sauerkraut |
| 44% | NOUGAT | 6 | Treat with nuts |
| 44% | OREO | 4 | Treat with milk |
| 44% | SCORN | 5 | Treat with contempt |
| 44% | FLOUT | 5 | Treat with scorn |