| 100% | CHESTNUT | 8 | Tree fruit that can be roasted on an open fire |
| 81% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Edible tree fruits, can be roasted on an open fire |
| 59% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Brown tree fruit roasted on an open fire |
| 57% | CAMPER | 6 | One may be roasting on an open fire |
| 49% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | __ roasting on an open fire |
| 49% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | "__ roasting on an open fire" |
| 48% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Christmas lyric, __ roasting on an open fire |
| 48% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | "__ roasting on an open fire" Christmas lyrics |
| 48% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | " ____ roasting on an open fire", popular carol |
| 47% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Christmas treats roasted on an open fire |
| 46% | CHESTNUTS | 9 | Buy these to roast on an open fire at Christmas |
| 46% | PEAR | 4 | Fruit that can be an Anjou or Bosc |
| 45% | HEAT | 4 | What one might feel near chestnuts roasting on an open fire |
| 44% | DOH | 3 | Catchphrase first intentionally used in December 1989 in "Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire" |
| 41% | APP | 3 | Item that can be placed in a folder on an iPhone |
| 40% | PICNIC | 6 | Informal meal at the beachside that could be a fun recreational activity on an island |
| 39% | ASIS | 4 | Warning on an item that can't be returned: 2 wds. |
| 39% | APPLE | 5 | Fruit that can be candied |
| 39% | RASPBERRIES | 11 | Fruit that can be blown |
| 38% | OPEN | 4 | "Simpsons Roasting on an ___ Fire," first episode of "The Simpsons" that aired as a Christmas special in 1989 |
| 38% | ROASTING | 8 | Chestnuts __ on an open fire |
| 38% | FIRE | 4 | "Chestnuts roasting on an open —" |
| 38% | CRANBERRY | 9 | Fruit that can be wet- or dry-picked |
| 38% | APPLES | 6 | Fruits that could be Honeycrisp or Pink Lady |
| 38% | SEED | 4 | Pumpkin part that can be roasted |
| 38% | SMORES | 6 | Treats prepared on an open fire |
| 38% | ROASTED | 7 | Cooked chestnuts on an open fire |
| 37% | GAMMON | 6 | Cured ham joint that can be roasted |
| 37% | POTHOOK | 7 | Way to cook on an open fire |
| 37% | OLIVE | 5 | Small fruit that can be black or green |