| 100% | FOES | 4 | Two-Face and the Riddler, to Batman |
| 75% | FOES | 4 | The Joker and the Riddler, to Batman |
| 63% | ENEMY | 5 | The Riddler, to Batman |
| 63% | FOE | 3 | The Riddler, to Batman |
| 57% | ENEMIES | 7 | The Joker and the Penguin, to Batman |
| 56% | FOE | 3 | The Joker or the Riddler, to Batman |
| 54% | NEMESIS | 7 | Batman, to the Riddler |
| 54% | NEMESES | 7 | Moriarty to Holmes and The Joker to Batman |
| 53% | ABRAHAM | 7 | Face to the right of George, Thomas and Theodore |
| 53% | NEMESES | 7 | Joker and Riddler, to Batman |
| 52% | FRESHASADAISY | 13 | Well rested and ready to face the day |
| 51% | SKINCARE | 8 | Routine of products to treat and protect the face |
| 51% | BALACLAVA | 9 | Head and face gear to protect against the cold |
| 51% | ALTEREGOS | 9 | Batman and the Hulk, to Bruce Wayne and Bruce Banner, respectively: 2 wds. |
| 50% | ERAS | 4 | The Gilded Age and Reconstruction, to name two |
| 50% | ABRAHAM | 7 | Mount Rushmore face to the right of George, Thomas, and Theodore |
| 49% | DST | 3 | What Ariz. and Hawaii are the only two states not to have |
| 49% | ODDS | 4 | Relationship often expressed with two numbers and the word to |
| 46% | TAXES | 5 | Death and ___ (the two certainties, according to Ben Franklin) |
| 46% | MILKMUSTACHE | 12 | Feature seen on the faces of Beyoncé, Batman, and Bart Simpson, in a famous ad campaign |
| 46% | SPORADES | 8 | Name given to two groups of Greek islands in the Aegean Sea; the Northern — and Southern — |
| 46% | HUEANDCRY | 9 | Public uproar … or a phonetic hint to the two words in 17-, 28- and 48-Across? |
| 45% | SEXANDTHECITY | 13 | Whence the line “Women come to New York in search of the two Ls: labels and love” |
| 45% | CHICAGO | 7 | Illinois city, home to the Lincoln Park Zoo, and host of two International Conferences on Climate Change |
| 44% | CATEBLANCHETT | 13 | "Blue Jasmine" and "The Aviator" star who was the first Australian to win Oscars in two acting categories (2 wds.) |
| 44% | NORTH | 5 | "___ Face," 2008 German historical fiction film that follows two climbers racing to scale a mountain in the Bernese Alps |
| 44% | WILL | 4 | I was one of the men in "Men in Black" and I'm also father to two singers |
| 44% | DESPERATEMEASURES | 17 | And the hopeless fourth movement resorted to... |
| 44% | SPLITENDS | 9 | Perm problem, and a hint to the four two-part answers |
| 43% | KUBO | 4 | "___ and the Two Strings" (2016 animated film) |