| 100% | RAT | 3 | Type of rodent that followed the Pied Piper |
| 87% | RAT | 3 | Animal that followed the Pied Piper |
| 75% | RAT | 3 | Type of animal the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 70% | RAT | 3 | Rodent that followed the Pied Piper |
| 70% | RATS | 4 | Rodents that followed the Pied Piper |
| 70% | RAT | 3 | Rodent that follows the Pied Piper |
| 68% | RATS | 4 | Rodents that followed the Pied Piper, in an old legend |
| 67% | LION | 4 | Type of animal that's the mayor in "Zootopia" |
| 65% | FROG | 4 | Type of animal that's the mascot for Honey Smacks cereal |
| 64% | WHITETIGER | 10 | Type of animal that Soohorang, the mascot of 35-Across, is: 2 wds. |
| 59% | RATS | 4 | Animals that the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 59% | RHUBARB | 7 | Type of pie made with strawberries that is popular with the Brits |
| 57% | POT | 3 | Chicken ___, type of pie that often has crust only on the top |
| 57% | DEER | 4 | Type of animal that Bambi is |
| 56% | ORCA | 4 | Type of animal that Shamu of SeaWorld is |
| 56% | DOLPHIN | 7 | Type of animal that played Flipper on TV |
| 56% | PIG | 3 | Type of animal that Babe is, in "Babe" |
| 56% | SNAIL | 5 | Type of animal that SpongeBob's pet is |
| 56% | LION | 4 | Type of animal that Narnia's Aslan is |
| 56% | RAT | 3 | Type of animal that Remy is, in "Ratatouille" |
| 55% | APE | 3 | Type of animal that was studied by Dian Fossey |
| 55% | LLAMA | 5 | Type of animal that Tina is, in "Napoleon Dynamite" |
| 54% | APE | 3 | Type of animal that's most closely related to humans |
| 53% | RAT | 3 | The Pied Piper of Hamelin, e.g. |
| 53% | RAT | 3 | Type of animal the Muppet Rizzo is |
| 52% | HAMELIN | 7 | "The Pied Piper of ___," poem written by Robert Browning that is based on a folktale |
| 52% | RUMINANT | 8 | Type of mammal that chews the cud |
| 52% | LASIK | 5 | Type of surgery that reshapes the cornea |
| 52% | BAD | 3 | Type of apple that spoils the bunch |
| 52% | RUGRATS | 7 | Cartoon that follows the adventures of toddlers |