| 100% | TAFT | 4 | U.S. president who sported a handlebar mustache |
| 54% | TAFT | 4 | Last U.S. president with a mustache |
| 50% | ARTHUR | 6 | Last U.S. president who never had a vice president |
| 48% | MONROE | 6 | Only U.S. President besides Washington for whom a world capital is named |
| 48% | SELA | 4 | Ward who played a U.S. president |
| 48% | JEFFERSON | 9 | A U.S. president who was also an architect, musician and inventor was … |
| 47% | BARACKOBAMA | 11 | U.S. president who has been listed on the TIME 100 a record 11 times (2 wds.) |
| 47% | HOOVER | 6 | US president who gave a dam |
| 47% | BERNIEBREWER | 12 | Milwaukee MLB team's mascot who has a handlebar mustache: 2 wds. |
| 47% | OBAMA | 5 | Former U.S. president who was honored with a Nobel Peace Prize in 2009 |
| 46% | RONALDREAGAN | 12 | U.S. President who signed the bill making Martin Luther King Jr.'s birthday a federal holiday (2 wds.) |
| 46% | OBAMA | 5 | US president who won a Nobel Peace Prize |
| 46% | TAFT | 4 | Last president to sport a mustache |
| 45% | VIOLA | 5 | Actress Davis who plays a U.S. President in “G20” |
| 44% | RICHARDNIXON | 12 | Former U.S. president who wrote "In the Arena: A Memoir of Victory, Defeat, and Renewal" (2 wds.) |
| 44% | TAFT | 4 | US president who was also a Chief Justice |
| 44% | HOOVER | 6 | US president after whom a dam is named |
| 44% | LABORUNION | 10 | Ronald Reagan is the only U.S. president who was also president of a … |
| 44% | POLKA | 5 | U.S. president + A |
| 44% | WARRENGHARDING | 14 | US president who had a pet squirrel named Pete: 3 wds. |
| 43% | CHESTER | 7 | U.S. president ___ A. Arthur |
| 43% | QUAYLE | 6 | Former US vice president who caused a student to spell "potato" incorrectly |
| 43% | TAFT | 4 | US president who was also a Supreme Court Chief Justice |
| 43% | RIHANNA | 7 | "Umbrella" hitmaker who sported a milk mustache in a "Got Milk?" ad |
| 43% | OBAMA | 5 | Former U.S. president who won a Best Spoken Word Album Grammy Award for the audiobook of "Dreams from My Father" |
| 43% | YOSEMITESAM | 11 | "Looney Tunes" cowboy who sports a red mustache (2 wds.) |
| 43% | COSMOSPACELY | 12 | "The Jetsons" boss who sports a black mustache (2 wds.) |
| 43% | NEDFLANDERS | 11 | "The Simpsons" neighbor who sports a brown mustache (2 wds.) |
| 42% | DRAGKING | 8 | Performer who might sport a fake mustache |
| 42% | TAFT | 4 | U.S. president who wrestled at Yale |