| 100% | WHALES | 6 | Underwater creatures that can echolocate |
| 55% | NENE | 4 | Creature that can walk on lava |
| 55% | NEWT | 4 | Creature that can be "red-spotted" |
| 54% | GECKOES | 7 | Creatures that can lick their own eyes |
| 54% | GECKO | 5 | Creature that can lick its own eyes |
| 53% | STARFISH | 8 | Creature that can shed its arms in defense |
| 53% | DUSTMITE | 8 | Tiny creature that can trigger allergies |
| 52% | ANT | 3 | Creature that can carry many times its body weight |
| 52% | EELS | 4 | Snaky sea creatures that can be electric |
| 52% | EELS | 4 | Long sea creatures that can swim backward |
| 51% | EELS | 4 | Creatures that can have two sets of jaws and teeth |
| 51% | OWLS | 4 | Creatures that can have asymmetrical ears, which aid in hunting |
| 51% | ORCA | 4 | Sea creature that can reach 26 feet long |
| 51% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Fictional creature that can transform into a bat |
| 51% | CRAB | 4 | Sea creature that can be made into "cakes" |
| 51% | ORCA | 4 | Sea creature that can weigh over six tons |
| 51% | SQUID | 5 | Sea creature that can change color to camouflage |
| 51% | PORPOISE | 8 | Creature that echolocates with a melon |
| 50% | FROGS | 5 | Creatures that can freeze and thaw to survive the winter cold |
| 50% | ALLIGATORS | 10 | Creatures that can regrow a lost tooth up to 50 times |
| 50% | BASILISK | 8 | Large serpent creature that can kill with a glance |
| 50% | BLUEWHALE | 9 | Marine creature that can weigh over 400,000 pounds |
| 50% | AUKS | 4 | Birds that can "fly" underwater |
| 50% | FLEA | 4 | Creature that can leap more than 150 times its own body length (!) |
| 49% | JELLYFISH | 9 | Stinging, soft-bodied sea animals...and creatures that can glow |
| 49% | NEOPET | 6 | Online creature that can be fed from a Giant Omelette |
| 49% | EMU | 3 | Creature that can fill the blank in L___R to make another creature |
| 49% | EELS | 4 | Moray ___ (snakelike sea creatures that can exceed nine feet in length) |
| 48% | SQUID | 5 | Vampire ___ (sea creature that can be jet black or blood-red) |
| 48% | LOON | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |