| 100% | MIRACLES | 8 | Unexplainable happenings, do you believe in them? |
| 49% | MAGIC | 5 | "Do You Believe in ___" (Lovin' Spoonful song) |
| 47% | ALMICHAELS | 10 | Sportscaster who memorably asked "Do you believe in miracles?" |
| 47% | CHER | 4 | She sang "Do you believe in life after love?" |
| 45% | SMH | 3 | "I can't believe you did that," in text shorthand |
| 44% | REBEL | 5 | "What do you call a kid who doesn't believe in Santa? A ___ without a Claus!" |
| 44% | ROMANS | 6 | When in Rome, it's said you should do as they do |
| 44% | FOLD | 4 | What you might do to shirts before putting them in a suitcase |
| 43% | GODS | 4 | Polytheists believe in them |
| 42% | SEE | 3 | "Now do you believe me?" |
| 42% | HARRIET | 7 | Did you know that the world's largest 1a was believed to have been lain by the British hen ___ in 2010? |
| 40% | YOURSELF | 8 | Express __, Madonna song, if you believe in love |
| 40% | HOW | 3 | "___ do you like them apples?" |
| 39% | APPLES | 6 | "How do you like them ___?" |
| 39% | APPLES | 6 | "How do you like them __?!" |
| 39% | AND | 3 | "I Believe in You ___ Me" |
| 39% | BANKON | 6 | Believe in something or rely on it happening |
| 39% | GODS | 4 | Polytheists believe in many of them |
| 39% | EMPHASISMINE | 12 | [Can you believe they wrote this?!] |
| 39% | SNOW | 4 | Did you know, icebergs in the oceans aren't salty as they form from glacier bits made of "this frozen ice form that falls as flakes"? |
| 38% | SEE | 3 | Happenings "___ You in September" |
| 38% | OMG | 3 | "Can you believe this?!" in chat rooms |
| 38% | TRUE | 4 | "Stay ___ to yourself!" ("Always believe in you!") |
| 38% | ESA | 3 | How do you say that in Spanish? |
| 38% | UTTERNONSENSE | 13 | What you find in eight of this puzzle's answers...or what you do when you say them aloud? |
| 37% | LASSO | 5 | Fictional soccer coach Ted who, when asked if he believes in ghosts, replies, "I do—but, more importantly, I think they need to believe in themselves” |
| 37% | BTW | 3 | "Hey, did you know..." in textspeak: Abbr. |
| 37% | TEETH | 5 | You put them in your food |
| 37% | NATIVES | 7 | You find them in your travels |
| 37% | ULNAS | 5 | You hold them in your arms |