| 100% | ROMANTIC | 8 | Valentine's Day is supposed to be this |
| 62% | FEBRUARY | 8 | Valentine's Day is celebrated in this month |
| 61% | SIC | 3 | [It's supposed to be wrong like this] |
| 60% | SIC | 3 | (It's supposed to be like this) |
| 57% | LOVELETTERS | 11 | Valentine's Day exchanges … or what this puzzle's shaded areas are? |
| 56% | HALF | 4 | "Better ___," phrase to describe your partner this Valentine's day |
| 56% | GARLIC | 6 | Vampires are supposed to keep away from this |
| 54% | ROSE | 4 | Valentine's day flower that is edible and used to infuse beverages, jellies, or jams |
| 54% | POTION | 6 | Love ___, magic concoction to make someone fall for you this Valentine's Day |
| 54% | LABNOTES | 8 | To this day, Marie Curie's are still radioactive |
| 53% | POOLTABLE | 9 | Image this puzzle grid is supposed to suggest |
| 53% | STEADY | 6 | Slow and this is supposed to win the race |
| 51% | VIDEOCALLS | 10 | What Zoomers are up to these days? |
| 50% | HEART | 5 | "Wear one's ___ on one's sleeve," phrase for someone who may be very confessional this Valentine's Day |
| 50% | FEB | 3 | When Valentine's Day is: Abbr. |
| 50% | ARROW | 5 | "Struck by Cupid's ___," phrase for a projectile said to make someone fall in love instantly this Valentine's Day |
| 49% | EARNEST | 7 | It's Wilde-ly important to be this |
| 49% | SALIVATE | 8 | Pavlov's dogs were conditioned to do this |
| 49% | WHO | 3 | "Am I supposed to know this person?" |
| 48% | IMAXFACTOR | 10 | One reason more people are going to the movies these days? |
| 48% | FEBRUARY | 8 | Month in which St Valentine's Day is celebrated |
| 47% | ROSE | 4 | Valentine's Day flower that is usually red |
| 47% | REHAB | 5 | It's supposed to be a sobering experience |
| 46% | POORMAN | 7 | Hamilton's Eliza is willing to be the wife of this |
| 46% | BRIMSTONE | 9 | God's wrath is said to be all fire and this |
| 46% | ROSE | 4 | Valentine's day flower that can also be "white" |
| 46% | ALLY | 4 | One who's supposed to be available if needed |
| 46% | BAYLEAF | 7 | Food flavorer that's not supposed to be eaten |
| 46% | FOXGLOVE | 8 | This plant's chemicals are used to make digoxin |
| 46% | TOOKFOR | 7 | Supposed to be |