| 100% | DAMONE | 6 | Vic with the 1949 #1 hit "You're Breaking My Heart" |
| 50% | DAMONE | 6 | "You're Breaking My Heart" singer Vic |
| 48% | ROD | 3 | ___ Stewart with the hit "You're in My Heart (The Final Acclaim)" |
| 47% | LOPOEZ | 6 | Singer with the 1999 #1 hit "If You Had My Love" |
| 44% | DEMI | 4 | Lovato with the hit "Give Your Heart a Break" |
| 44% | MEND | 4 | "How Can You ___ a Broken Heart" (#1 hit for the Bee Gees) |
| 44% | LOVATO | 6 | Demi with the 2012 hit "Give Your Heart a Break" |
| 42% | MEND | 4 | "How Can You ___ a Broken Heart" (No. 1 hit for the Bee Gees) |
| 41% | VIC | 3 | "You're Breaking My Heart" crooner Damone |
| 41% | MANEATER | 8 | 1982 No. 1 hit with the line “Watch out, boy, she’ll chew you up” |
| 41% | LOURAWLS | 8 | Singer with the #1 R&B hit "You'll Never Find Another Love Like Mine" |
| 41% | LUKECOMBS | 9 | Singer of the 2019 country hit "Beer Never Broke My Heart": 2 wds. |
| 40% | TONIBRAXTON | 11 | Singer with the 1996 #1 hit "You're Makin' Me High" |
| 40% | IMONFIRE | 8 | Springsteen hit with the lyric "Only you can cool my desire" |
| 40% | LOEB | 4 | Lisa with the #1 hit "Stay (I Missed You)" |
| 40% | WAITS | 5 | John with the 1984 #1 hit "Missing You" |
| 39% | RETURNTOME | 10 | Dean Martin love song with the lyrics "For my heart wants you only / Hurry home, hurry home" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | ENRIQUEIGLESIAS | 15 | Singer with the 2000 #1 hit "Be With You" |
| 39% | LANZA | 5 | Mario with the 1951 #1 hit "Be My Love" |
| 39% | INXS | 4 | Band with the 1988 #1 hit "Need You Tonight" |
| 39% | SHEERAN | 7 | Ed with the 2017 #1 hit "Shape of You" |
| 39% | LOLA | 4 | Hit song with the line "When she squeezed me tight she nearly broke my spine" |
| 39% | CHAKAKHAN | 9 | Singer with the #1 R&B hit "I Feel for You" |
| 39% | BREAD | 5 | Band with the 1970 #1 hit "Make It with You" |
| 39% | SAYER | 5 | Leo with the 1977 #1 hit "When I Need You" |
| 39% | LOEB | 4 | Lisa with the 1994 #1 hit "Stay (I Missed You)" |
| 39% | ESOBESO | 7 | 1962 hit with the lyric "Like the samba sound, my heart begins to pound" |
| 38% | GIVEMEONEREASON | 15 | Tracy Chapman hit with the lyric “This youthful heart can love you” |
| 38% | WHITNEYHOUSTON | 14 | Singer with seven consecutive #1 singles, from "Saving All My Love for You" to "Where Do Broken Hearts Go": 2 wds. |
| 38% | ASTLEY | 6 | Rick with the 1988 #1 hit "Never Gonna Give You Up" |