| 100% | PSI | 3 | What Indiana University's superimposed "I" and "U" looks like |
| 62% | PSI | 3 | Greek letter that Indiana University's "I" and "U" logo looks like |
| 50% | PHI | 3 | Greek letter that looks like an I and O superimposed |
| 40% | IBELIEVESO | 10 | "That's what it looks like to me" |
| 36% | LIKE | 4 | "It's not what it looks ___," cliche dialogue that's said in many movies like "Blades of Glory" and "The Matrix" |
| 35% | DOTTED | 6 | Like lowercase i's and j's |
| 35% | ATWAR | 5 | Like the U.S. and Spain in 1898 |
| 35% | WATERMARKED | 11 | Like U.S. passports and high-value banknotes |
| 35% | PEPSI | 5 | "That's what I like" brand |
| 35% | PEPSI | 5 | "That's What I Like" cola |
| 34% | DOMED | 5 | Like the U.S. Capitol and the Taj Mahal |
| 34% | HAZY | 4 | Like some weather, memories and I.P.A.s |
| 34% | MARS | 4 | "That's What I Like" singer Bruno |
| 34% | BRUNO | 5 | "That's What I Like" singer Mars |
| 34% | BERRA | 5 | Athlete who said "I looked like this when I was young, and I still do" |
| 34% | PEPSI | 5 | Cola brand with the slogan "That's what I like" |
| 33% | DOI | 3 | "___ look like I'm joking?" |
| 33% | NEWEST | 6 | Like Indiana Dunes among the U.S.'s 61 national parks |
| 33% | MIAMI | 5 | U.S. metropolis with neighborhoods like South Beach and Little Havana |
| 33% | BRUNOMARS | 9 | "That's What I Like" Grammy winner: 2 wds. |
| 32% | ITS | 3 | "And every time I look at you, ___ like the first time" |
| 32% | MASK | 4 | What a raccoon looks like it's wearing |
| 32% | RTES | 4 | I-80 and U.S. 10, e.g. |
| 32% | DRY | 3 | Like somebody under an umbrella, and what's added to four starred answers |
| 32% | WET | 3 | Like somebody without an umbrella, and what's added to four starred answers |
| 32% | PARITY | 6 | What the U.S. and Canadian dollars had, roughly, in the early 2010s |
| 32% | LOUISCK | 7 | Comic who said "I open my eyes, remember who I am, what I'm like, and I just go 'Ugh'" |
| 32% | LASS | 4 | Narrator and protagonist Georgia "George" ___ of Showtime's "Dead Like Me" |
| 32% | IMAGONER | 8 | "This looks like the end for me!" |
| 32% | DIRTY | 5 | Like some looks and laundry |