| 100% | VAT | 3 | What Jack Napier fell into, to become the Joker |
| 40% | BEANSTALK | 9 | What Jack climbed to meet the giant |
| 37% | PUCK | 4 | What hockey players try to shoot into the net |
| 35% | PILOT | 5 | What Barbie becomes when she takes to the skies and flies planes |
| 33% | BRANDED | 7 | Labeled ... or, divided into three parts, what surrounds the answers to starred clues |
| 33% | SPUN | 4 | What was done to the straw given to the miller's daughter to turn into gold |
| 33% | THEMAYFLOWER | 12 | English ship that brought the Pilgrims to what would become 32-Across (2 wds.) |
| 33% | PUCK | 4 | What a hockey player tries to shoot into the goal |
| 32% | ENEMY | 5 | The Joker, to Batman |
| 32% | FOE | 3 | The Joker, to Batman |
| 32% | GETPLAYED | 9 | Fall for it, or what can happen to the last words of 17-, 25-, 38- and 56-Across |
| 32% | TOOKTO | 6 | Fell into the habit of |
| 31% | GRANDPA | 7 | Pop's pop ... or, divided into three parts, what the answers to starred clues have in common |
| 31% | CHANCEENCOUNTER | 15 | Bumping into someone, say ... and what the end of each answer to a starred clue can have? |
| 31% | APPEAR | 6 | To become visible, come into sight |
| 31% | FOE | 3 | The Joker or Catwoman, to Batman |
| 31% | AHEADOF | 7 | Leading, or, when parsed differently, what can lead into the starts of the answers to the starred clues |
| 31% | FEEDINGFRENZY | 13 | Mad rush for spoils ... or what the answers to 17-, 25-, 51-, and 60-Across have descended into? |
| 31% | GOTWET | 6 | Fell into the pool, say: 2 wds. |
| 31% | FOE | 3 | The Joker or the Riddler, to Batman |
| 31% | ENEMIES | 7 | The Joker and the Penguin, to Batman |
| 31% | FOES | 4 | The Joker and the Riddler, to Batman |
| 31% | PAILOFWATER | 11 | What Jack went to fetch with Jill |
| 30% | DISUSE | 6 | What old things fall into |
| 30% | NUN | 3 | What Maria is planning to become at the start of "The Sound of Music" |
| 30% | STEVIENICKS | 11 | American singer and songwriter who became the first woman to be inducted twice into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame: 2 wds. |
| 30% | ABANDON | 7 | Leave high and dry ... or, when divided into three parts, what the answers to starred clues are encompassed by |
| 30% | PAIL | 4 | What Jack and Jill took up the hill |
| 30% | PAIL | 4 | What Jack and Jill carried up the hill |
| 30% | SANK | 4 | Fell to the seabed |