| 100% | CROONERSINQUEST | 15 | What might determine if the moon hitting your eye like a big pizza pie is truly amore? |
| 61% | AMORE | 5 | What you feel "when the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie" |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | "When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie" emotion |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | "When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie," apparently |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | "That's ___!" (when the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie) |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | “When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie, that’s ___” |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | "When the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie, that's ___" |
| 57% | AMORE | 5 | Cause of the moon hitting your eye like a big pizza pie, in song |
| 49% | PIZZAPIE | 8 | "When the moon hits your eye like a big ___, that's amore" (Dean Martin lyric) |
| 32% | AMORE | 5 | "When the moon hits your eye" feeling, in a Dean Martin song |
| 29% | EJECT | 5 | What a fighter pilot might do from the cockpit if the plane is hit |
| 29% | AMORE | 5 | “... like a big pizza pie, that’s ___” |
| 28% | AMORE | 5 | "When the moon hits your eye" feeling |
| 26% | HAND | 4 | "Raise your ___," what students might be instructed to do in school if they have a question |
| 25% | NOONE | 5 | Who "knows what it's like to be the bad man," according to a 1971 hit by the Who |
| 25% | BROKENBAT | 9 | What might go flying after a big hit |
| 25% | AMORE | 5 | "...like a big pizza pie, that's ___" (old song lyric) |
| 25% | SOCKS | 5 | What might be between your skin and the shoes |
| 25% | PRIZE | 5 | What may be on the line in a competition |
| 25% | STARRY | 6 | Like a night on which the Big Dipper is visible |
| 24% | EIGHTHS | 7 | What a pie might be sliced into |
| 24% | EGOTRIP | 7 | What a big winner might be on |
| 24% | PROSHOP | 7 | What might be in trouble if it's out of the woods? |
| 24% | ASL | 3 | What might be seen in the corner of a TV screen: Abbr. |
| 24% | EGGS | 4 | What the six geese might be a-laying |
| 24% | COAL | 4 | What a snowman's eyes might be made of |
| 23% | OUTOFORDER | 10 | Like a nonfunctioning vending machine, or what the circled letters are, in two ways |
| 23% | POT | 3 | What may be at stake as a result of the ruling at 37-Across |
| 23% | MUSH | 4 | What your brain might feel like after a long day |
| 23% | LAST | 4 | What you might be if you're a rotten egg? |