| 100% | MITT | 4 | What to catch a fly ball with |
| 54% | OUTS | 4 | What tagging a runner and catching a fly ball result in |
| 52% | MITT | 4 | Glove that could catch a fly ball |
| 49% | TAGSUP | 6 | Retouches after a fly ball is caught |
| 49% | AIL | 3 | To catch a bug or be ill (rhymes with "snail") |
| 49% | DEEP | 4 | Like a fly ball to the warning track |
| 49% | SAW | 3 | What to cut a plank with |
| 49% | PEN | 3 | What to sign a contract with |
| 48% | FUMBLE | 6 | Act clumsily with the hands; fail to catch a ball |
| 48% | DEEP | 4 | Like a fly ball hit to the warning track |
| 48% | STIR | 4 | What to do with a coffee spoon |
| 48% | HOTLINE | 7 | What to call with in a crisis |
| 47% | PEN | 3 | What to sign a credit card slip with |
| 47% | DROP | 4 | Fail to catch, as a ball |
| 47% | MISS | 4 | Fail to catch, as a thrown ball |
| 47% | SIEVE | 5 | What's a strain to cook with? |
| 46% | GROUNDER | 8 | Alternative to a fly ball |
| 46% | AAH | 3 | What to say to a doctor with a tongue depressor |
| 46% | TAIL | 4 | What a cow swats flies with |
| 45% | FISH | 4 | Try to catch something with a rod and reel |
| 45% | FLAP | 4 | What birds do with their wings to fly |
| 45% | TEED | 4 | Prepared to drive a golf ball, with “up” |
| 44% | RAP | 3 | What a suspect tries to beat, with "the" |
| 44% | WARMWATER | 9 | What a faucet provides to wash up with |
| 44% | TAIL | 4 | What a cow uses to swat flies away |
| 44% | OUTOFBREATH | 11 | What racing to catch a bus may cause you to be |
| 44% | FLAP | 4 | What a bird does to its wings to fly |
| 44% | KITE | 4 | What a kid could fly with a string attached |
| 44% | JUGGLES | 7 | What a circus performer does with balls or knives |
| 44% | BAD | 3 | With 2-Down, what a villain may come to |