| 100% | WISHUPON | 8 | When You __ a Star, Pinocchio song |
| 70% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | When You Wish Upon a star is a song in this film |
| 68% | WISH | 4 | "When You ___ Upon a Star" ("Pinocchio" song) |
| 60% | UPON | 4 | "When You Wish ___ a Star" (song from "Pinocchio") |
| 59% | SEXSCENE | 8 | When you might see a star's moon? |
| 54% | HUM | 3 | What to do when you don't know the words to a song |
| 51% | STAR | 4 | "When You Wish Upon A ___," song from Disney's film "Pinocchio" sung by Cliff Edwards |
| 50% | STAR | 4 | "When You Wish Upon a ___" (song from "Pinocchio") |
| 49% | WISH | 4 | You might make one when you see a falling star |
| 49% | WISH | 4 | "When You __ Upon a Star" |
| 49% | UPON | 4 | "When You Wish __ a Star" |
| 48% | THAT | 4 | "I get ___ drunk sex feeling, yeah, when I'm with you" (lyric from a 2012 song) |
| 48% | UPON | 4 | "When you Wish ___ a Star" |
| 48% | UPON | 4 | "When you wish ___ a star ..." |
| 48% | UPON | 4 | ''When you wish __ a star . . .'' |
| 48% | UPON | 4 | ''When You Wish __ a Star'' |
| 48% | WISH | 4 | "When You ___ Upon a Star" |
| 48% | UPON | 4 | "When you wish ___ a star..." |
| 47% | NED | 3 | "When You Wish Upon a Star" lyricist Washington |
| 47% | MOVINGDAY | 9 | When you might rent a van |
| 47% | SPARETIME | 9 | When you might solve a puzzle |
| 46% | MAMA | 4 | When You're Good to ___ ("Chicago" song) |
| 46% | DOODAD | 6 | When you can't remember a name |
| 46% | ETA | 3 | When you can expect a touchdown (abbr.) |
| 46% | ATBAT | 5 | When you might feast on a slider? |
| 46% | TAE | 3 | When You Trap a Tiger author Keller |
| 46% | UPON | 4 | “When you wish ___ a star . . .” |
| 46% | LETITSNOW | 9 | When tripled, a holiday song |
| 45% | DIPLOMA | 7 | When you graduate high school, you get a __ |