| 100% | ANY | 3 | Which card to pick, according to a magician |
| 84% | ANY | 3 | Which card to pick, according to some magicians |
| 80% | ANY | 3 | Which card to pick from a magician? |
| 59% | ANY | 3 | The card a magician might ask you to pick |
| 50% | CARD | 4 | A magician might ask you to pick one |
| 44% | ADO | 3 | Unnecessary commotion (which according to a saying is about nothing) |
| 43% | TOE{LO}OP | 9 | Jump in which a figure skater uses the pick to launch |
| 42% | HOW | 3 | Question to a magician |
| 42% | INT | 3 | Pick, to a QB |
| 42% | OLDMAID | 7 | Victorian card game in which players collect pairs and try not to be left with a penalty card |
| 42% | TREVI | 5 | Fountain into which, according to legend, one can toss a coin to guarantee a future return to Rome |
| 41% | PROP | 4 | Top hat, to a magician |
| 41% | OLD | 3 | & 20D Victorian card game in which players collect pairs and try not to be left with a penalty card |
| 41% | CHEST | 5 | * Wow! You've landed on "Community ___," pick a card to collect money (Move 3 spaces for the next answer) |
| 41% | MIND | 4 | "A terrible thing to waste," according to a saying |
| 41% | IDES | 4 | Date to beware, according to a Shakespearean soothsayer |
| 41% | PROP | 4 | Rabbit or a top hat, to a magician |
| 41% | CHOOSING | 8 | Selecting, deciding which option to pick |
| 41% | SEX | 3 | It sells, according to a saying |
| 41% | ERR | 3 | Act human, according to a proverb |
| 41% | OLDDOG | 6 | Poor learner, according to a proverb |
| 41% | ERR | 3 | Be human, according to a saying |
| 41% | ROARSCHACHTESTS | 15 | Inkblot interpretations ... according to a lion? |
| 40% | RATE | 4 | Assign a value according to a standard |
| 40% | ERR | 3 | What humans do, according to a saying |
| 40% | HONESTY | 7 | "The best policy," according to a saying |
| 40% | EASY | 4 | Like Sunday morning, according to a song |
| 40% | ONE | 3 | "The loneliest number," according to a song |
| 40% | HONESTY | 7 | The best policy, according to a saying |