| 100% | TIE | 3 | Why a baseball game would go into the 10th inning |
| 40% | FLYBALL | 7 | A baseball hit that goes high up into the air |
| 40% | TIE | 3 | Why a game might go into sudden death |
| 35% | TENTH | 5 | Numerically, the first extra inning in a baseball game |
| 34% | INCEPTION | 9 | A DiCaprio film about going into the subconscious |
| 33% | BENCHJOHNNY | 11 | Make a baseball player sit out the game? |
| 32% | BAT | 3 | Item a baseball player takes into the on-deck circle |
| 31% | NINTH | 5 | Last inning of a baseball game, usually |
| 31% | TIED | 4 | Like a game heading into extra innings |
| 31% | NINTH | 5 | Last inning of a baseball game, most likely |
| 31% | EXTRA | 5 | Like a 10th or 11th inning, in baseball |
| 30% | DISREPUTE | 9 | Bringing the game into __; e.g. a football scandal |
| 30% | NEXTLEVEL | 9 | Advancing in a video game means going to the __ |
| 29% | HID | 3 | Went into the closet |
| 29% | TIE | 3 | Reason for extra innings in a baseball game |
| 29% | DIVE | 4 | Go off a board into the deep end |
| 29% | PINE | 4 | Ride the ___ (sit out a baseball game) |
| 29% | SOAR | 4 | Go into the wild blue yonder |
| 29% | DOVE | 4 | Went into the deep end, perhaps |
| 28% | LEG | 3 | Limb with which you would kick the ball in a game of soccer |
| 28% | UMPING | 6 | Officiating a baseball game |
| 28% | ISITCAKE | 8 | Netflix game show where the host may cut into a handbag (3 wds.) |
| 28% | TIE | 3 | Cause of a game going into overtime |
| 28% | INNINGS | 7 | Frames of a baseball game |
| 28% | LOSING | 6 | Behind in a baseball game |
| 28% | WILDPITCH | 9 | *Boo during a baseball game |
| 28% | TIED | 4 | How a baseball game starts |
| 28% | UMPED | 5 | Officiated at a baseball game |
| 28% | SHUTOUT | 7 | In baseball or ice hockey, a game where the losing side fails to score |
| 28% | NOHIT | 5 | A game in baseball when the opposing team fails to record a single base hit: 2 wds. |