| 100% | GLORIA | 6 | With 39-Across, "I Am What I Am" |
| 73% | STATE | 5 | With 39 Across and 33 Down, what each syllable of the answer to each starred clue is |
| 71% | REEBOK | 6 | Company with the campaign, "I Am What I Am" |
| 63% | BILLIE | 6 | With 19-Across, "What Was I Made For?" singer |
| 60% | SLASHERFILM | 11 | Movie with graphic violence ... or what 17-Across, 22-Down or 39-Down each is? |
| 59% | MONO | 4 | With 27 Across, what 1 Across/5 Across is accused of becoming |
| 58% | STEALTH | 7 | With 88 Across, what this diagram is an aerial view of (eight, to be exact) |
| 58% | QANDU | 5 | What can be added to 39 and 40 Across to form new words |
| 58% | DRY | 3 | With 10 Across, what cannot be seen in the house after a tearjerker |
| 58% | TWOHUNDREDTH | 12 | With 41 and 55 Across, what 15 Across is |
| 57% | FOREIGNER | 9 | Rock band with 80s hit I Want To Know What Love Is |
| 57% | CROSSWORDPUZZLE | 15 | With 37- and 56-Across, what this is |
| 56% | OWNSIT | 6 | Says "I am what I am" |
| 56% | ZIP | 3 | With 12-Across, what 90210 is |
| 55% | HOS | 3 | Sounds from Santa (and what's been added to 17, 39, and 63 Across) |
| 55% | BLACKDOG | 8 | 52-Across song with the lyrics "At least I know that you are trying / But that's what makes it terrifying" (2 wds.) |
| 55% | QUOD | 4 | "Eris ___ sum" ("You will be what I am") |
| 55% | HER | 3 | With 22-Across, what Johnny was to Frankie |
| 55% | ROBERTFROSTPOEM | 15 | What 17- and 39-Across is |
| 55% | ISIS | 4 | Dylan song with the line "What drives me to you is what drives me insane" |
| 54% | EFGH | 4 | What I will follow |
| 54% | NURSERYRHYMES | 13 | What 20-Across and 39-Across are |
| 54% | ONE | 3 | What I will always be? |
| 54% | NINTH | 5 | What I will always be? |
| 54% | TORONTO | 7 | With 39 Across, Canadian baseballer |
| 54% | HOLDTHESETRUTHS | 15 | With 39 Across, ''We'' follower |
| 53% | BEL | 3 | With 39-Across, Peacock series based on a 1990s Will Smith show |
| 53% | INFINITE | 8 | With 9-Across, informally, what aleph-null is, in mathematics |
| 53% | ONE | 3 | With 47-Across, what a mononymous person is known by |
| 53% | TOLDYA | 6 | "See? I knew what I was talking about!" |