| 100% | PILEDUP | 7 | With 57-Down, drift |
| 83% | SRI | 3 | With 57 Down, island republic |
| 79% | YOO | 3 | With 57 Down, something to make you look |
| 75% | ERIC | 4 | With 57-Across, "Black Hawk Down" actor |
| 70% | AGE | 3 | With 57-Down, ancient |
| 68% | ALL | 3 | With 57-Down, very nearly |
| 68% | ACT | 3 | With 57-Down, commercial entreaty |
| 68% | CUTS | 4 | With 57-Down, noble title |
| 67% | ILIKE | 5 | With 57-Down, 1950s campaign slogan |
| 67% | MIR | 3 | With 57-Down, no-no #3 |
| 67% | PIE | 3 | With 57-Down, something filling fills |
| 67% | ORE | 3 | With 57-Down, Tater Tots maker |
| 67% | MEET | 4 | With 57-Down, rom-com trope |
| 67% | IVE | 3 | Suffix with 57-Down |
| 66% | LOIS | 4 | With 57-Down, star reporter of fiction |
| 66% | COCA | 4 | With 57-Down, soft drink since 1886 |
| 66% | SEES | 4 | With 57-Down, loses one's cool |
| 66% | PINE | 4 | With 57-Down, car air freshener shape |
| 66% | CLAWFOOT | 8 | With 57-Down, old-fashioned bathroom fixture |
| 65% | SOUP | 4 | With 57-Down, memorable "Seinfeld" character, with "the" |
| 65% | BREAK | 5 | With 57-Down, part of a morning routine |
| 65% | ILIKE | 5 | With 57-Down, Eisenhower campaign slogan: 2 wds. |
| 64% | AIKEN | 5 | "Idol" runner-up, with 57-Down |
| 63% | HOT | 3 | With 57-Down, worst-case scenario for careless whispers? |
| 63% | AQUA | 4 | With 57-Down, fitness class held in a pool |
| 62% | MRS | 3 | ___ Miller (Julie Christie title role with 57-Down) |
| 61% | BUT | 3 | With 57-Down, possible response to 20-, 31- or 39-Across |
| 59% | SINGLE | 6 | With 57-Across, ice cream order depicted at 14-Down |
| 59% | DOUBLE | 6 | With 57-Across, ice cream order depicted at 31-Down |
| 59% | TRIPLE | 6 | With 57-Across, ice cream order depicted at 56-Down |