| 100% | WYATT | 5 | With 65-Down, brother of Virgil and Morgan |
| 71% | WYATT | 5 | Brother of Virgil and Morgan Earp |
| 63% | WYATT | 5 | Brother of Morgan and Virgil |
| 51% | EARPS | 5 | Brothers Wyatt, Virgil and Morgan |
| 48% | JOHNB | 5 | With 65-Across, Irish writer and author of the quote |
| 46% | CRIME | 5 | With 65-Across, investigation site, and a punny description of the HEIST answers |
| 45% | THOMAS | 6 | With 9 Down and 71 Across, source of quote |
| 45% | OLIVE | 5 | With 65-Down, toon sister of Castor |
| 45% | NEAR | 4 | With 65-Across, the starts of 20-, 26-, 43- and 51-Across taken together |
| 45% | LIFEWITHOUT | 11 | With 65 Across, what some 1992 and '96 voters dreamed of? |
| 45% | EARPS | 5 | Wyatt, Morgan and Virgil of the Wild West |
| 44% | GROUCHO | 7 | Part of the Marx brothers with Chico and Harpo |
| 43% | EYE | 3 | With 65-Across, what the last words of 18-, 35- and 56-Across are to each other |
| 43% | FAST | 4 | With 65 Down, flimflam |
| 42% | SPLIT | 5 | With 65-Across, chore on a winter to-do list ... and what appears in each set of circles |
| 42% | SAINT | 5 | With 79 Down, canonized Norwegian king and the namesake of a Minnesota college |
| 42% | AMES | 4 | Surname of brothers with 38 chart hits in the '40s and '50s |
| 41% | CURLY | 5 | Stooge with a shaved head, brother of 15-Across and 9-Down |
| 41% | SIGMA | 5 | With 65-Down, 160-year-old fraternity founded at Miami University of Ohio |
| 41% | SINE | 4 | Curve with lots of ups and downs |
| 41% | LATIN | 5 | Language of Virgil and Catullus |
| 40% | TINY | 4 | With 35-Down, brother of Master Peter |
| 40% | STATE | 5 | With 39 Across and 33 Down, what each syllable of the answer to each starred clue is |
| 40% | BALD | 4 | With ''-faced'' and 65 Down, whopper |
| 40% | DAMON | 5 | Stand-up comic and co-creator of "In living color" with his brother Keenen Wayans |
| 40% | SCARY | 5 | With 1-Down, bandmate of Sporty, Baby, Ginger, and Posh |
| 39% | FROST | 5 | Example of 65-Across and 39-Down |
| 39% | HARPO | 5 | Brother of Chico and Groucho |
| 39% | LOUIE | 5 | Brother of Huey and Dewey |