| 100% | GIFT | 4 | Wrapped-up surprise found under the Christmas tree |
| 55% | GIFTS | 5 | They are found wrapped under a Christmas tree |
| 54% | PINENEEDLE | 10 | Item under the Christmas tree |
| 54% | PRESENTS | 8 | Items under the Christmas tree |
| 49% | OFFLIMITS | 9 | What presents left under the Christmas tree are considered before Christmas morning, perhaps |
| 48% | GIFT | 4 | Wrapped-up item under a Christmas tree |
| 48% | GHOSTLYPRESENTS | 15 | What's found under Casper's Christmas tree? |
| 48% | NEEDLES | 7 | They might be found under a Christmas tree |
| 46% | GIFT | 4 | Wrapped thing under a Christmas tree |
| 46% | GIFT | 4 | Wrapped box under a Christmas tree |
| 46% | PRESENTS | 8 | Wrapped items under a Christmas tree |
| 46% | PRESENT | 7 | Wrapped package under a Christmas tree |
| 43% | NEEDLE | 6 | You might find one under a Christmas tree |
| 40% | BAUBLE | 6 | Colorful spherical trinket hung on the Christmas tree |
| 40% | LIT | 3 | Like the Christmas tree |
| 40% | PEARL | 5 | Gem found under the sea? |
| 40% | COAL | 4 | Rock around the Christmas tree? |
| 39% | BEDBUGS | 7 | Bloodsucking insects found under the duvet |
| 39% | BRENDALEE | 9 | "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree" singer |
| 38% | URANIUMORE | 10 | It may be found under the counter |
| 38% | BATTERY | 7 | Important car component found under the hood |
| 38% | ROCKIN | 6 | Brenda Lee's "___ Around the Christmas Tree" |
| 38% | VICTORIA | 8 | Queen who popularized the Christmas tree tradition |
| 38% | BRENDA | 6 | "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree", sang __ Lee |
| 38% | BRENDA | 6 | “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” singer Lee |
| 38% | LEE | 3 | Brenda ___, "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree" singer |
| 38% | XXX | 3 | "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree" singer Brenda |
| 38% | NATIONAL | 8 | ___ Christmas Tree, iconic tree on display in the Ellipse, Washington D.C. that is lit up by the President and First Lady |
| 38% | KEGS | 4 | They're found under the counter at bars |
| 38% | ROCKIN | 6 | With 16 Across, "___ the Christmas Tree" (Brenda Lee) |