| 100% | BEAST | 5 | X-Men hero whose other identity is Hank McCoy |
| 45% | BATMAN | 6 | Hero whose secret identity is Bruce Wayne |
| 41% | IRON | 4 | ___ Man (superhero whose secret identity is Tony Stark) |
| 33% | IRON | 4 | ___ Man, the Marvel hero whose real name is Tony Stark |
| 32% | GAMBIT | 6 | Part-time X-Men member whose name is Remy LeBeau |
| 32% | HAN | 3 | Movie hero whose copilot is Chewbacca |
| 31% | ICEMAN | 6 | X-Men character whose real name is Robert Drake |
| 31% | COLOSSUS | 8 | X-Men character whose real name is Piotr Rasputin |
| 31% | MYSTIQUE | 8 | X-Men character whose real name is Raven Darkhölme |
| 31% | BAMBI | 5 | Disney title hero whose mate is Faline |
| 31% | BILBO | 5 | "The Hobbit" hero whose cousin is Frodo |
| 31% | EMMAFROST | 9 | "X-Men" hero who is a telepath: 2 wds. |
| 31% | ASLAN | 5 | Literary hero whose name is Turkish for "lion" |
| 31% | ZORRO | 5 | Fictional hero whose name is Spanish for "fox" |
| 31% | ROYHARPER | 9 | DC hero whose name was Speedy then Arsenal |
| 31% | ELSE | 4 | Being somebody other, a different identity |
| 31% | KING | 4 | Man whose home is his castle |
| 30% | HECTOR | 6 | Iliad hero whose body is dragged behind Achilles’ chariot |
| 30% | IRONMAN | 7 | Hero whose real name is Tony Stark: 2 wds. |
| 30% | EMMAFROST | 9 | X-Men anti-hero whose aliases include White Queen |
| 30% | FRANKABAGNALE | 13 | Con man whose fake identities in the 1960s were depicted in "Catch Me If You Can": 2 wds. |
| 30% | DOE | 3 | John ___ (man whose identity is unknown) |
| 29% | CHASE | 5 | Man whose portrait was on $10,000 bills |
| 29% | TOHIS | 5 | "No man is a hero ___ valet" |
| 29% | AJAX | 4 | Trojan War hero whose name is also a brand of cleanser |
| 29% | ELENA | 5 | Author Ferrante whose true identity is unknown |
| 29% | CARNIVORE | 9 | An animal whose diet is other animals |
| 29% | INXS | 4 | Band whose front man was Michael Hutchence |
| 29% | REM | 3 | Band whose front man was Michael Stipe |
| 28% | WOLVERINE | 9 | Marvel comic book hero whose metal claw noise is written as "SNIKT" |