| 100% | MDIV | 4 | XII years after Columbus's first voyage |
| 47% | MDII | 4 | Year of Columbus's last voyage |
| 43% | MDII | 4 | Ten years after Columbus came over |
| 38% | MDII | 4 | Year Columbus began his last voyage |
| 37% | MDII | 4 | Year Columbus' fourth and last voyage began |
| 35% | STLOUISBLUES | 12 | Central Division team that won the franchise's first-ever Stanley Cup in 2019, after 52 years: 3 wds. |
| 35% | DENVERNUGGETS | 13 | Northwest Division team that won the franchise's first-ever NBA Championship in 2023, after 56 years: 2 wds. |
| 35% | TEXASRANGERS | 12 | AL West team that won the franchise's first-ever World Series in 2023, after 62 years: 2 wds. |
| 35% | MDIV | 4 | Year Columbus returned from his final voyage to the New World |
| 34% | MDVI | 4 | Year of Columbus's death |
| 34% | DEC | 3 | First month after fall or last month of the year, for short |
| 33% | MAIDEN | 6 | First, as a ship's voyage |
| 31% | MAIDEN | 6 | First voyage |
| 31% | ONE | 3 | Pi's first digit after the decimal |
| 31% | DCCI | 4 | First year of John VI's papacy |
| 31% | MAIDEN | 6 | ___ voyage (ship's first sailing) |
| 31% | EVE | 3 | Word after "New Year's" |
| 31% | MMI | 3 | Year after Y2K |
| 30% | NEHRU | 5 | India's first prime minister after 1947 partition |
| 30% | CXL | 3 | First year in St. Pius I's papacy |
| 30% | MDL | 3 | Year Nostradamus's first almanac was written |
| 30% | MDVI | 4 | Year of Christopher Columbus's death |
| 30% | ONELS | 5 | Some first-years after undergrad |
| 30% | CCCVI | 5 | First year in Constantine's reign |
| 30% | THEMANDALORIAN | 14 | "Star Wars" spinoff set five years after Emperor Palpatine's fall |
| 30% | ONE | 3 | First digit after the decimal in Pi's value |
| 30% | SEVENTY | 7 | San Diego Comic-Con's first year was Nineteen __ |
| 29% | EVE | 3 | Word after "Christmas" or "New Year's" |
| 29% | EVE | 3 | Word after "New Year's" or "Christmas" |
| 29% | ONINE | 5 | First year of Obama's presidency, slangily |