| 100% | ALMAMATER | 9 | Yale, for five U.S. presidents |
| 94% | ALMAMATER | 9 | *Yale, for five U.S. presidents |
| 80% | YALE | 4 | Alma mater for five U.S. presidents |
| 63% | BEARD | 5 | Feature of five U.S. Presidents |
| 60% | YALE | 4 | Alma mater of five U.S. presidents |
| 59% | EMPIRESTATE | 11 | Birthplace of five U.S. presidents, with "the" |
| 59% | OHIO | 4 | State where five U.S. presidents are buried |
| 59% | ELKS | 4 | Order whose members have included five U.S. presidents |
| 58% | TAFT | 4 | U.S. president who wrestled at Yale |
| 58% | BEARD | 5 | Feature of five U.S. presidents from Lincoln to Harrison |
| 57% | POWDEREDWIG | 11 | Accessory for early U.S. presidents |
| 56% | FDR | 3 | Longest-serving U.S. President, for short |
| 56% | DECATUR | 7 | Naval hero with five U.S. counties named for him |
| 55% | ELKS | 4 | Group to which five U.S. presidents have belonged, from Harding to Ford |
| 54% | SILENTCAL | 9 | Nickname for U.S. president #30 |
| 53% | IKE | 3 | Nickname for U.S. President D. Eisenhower |
| 53% | ADAMS | 5 | Last name for 2 U.S. presidents |
| 52% | TERM | 4 | Four years for a U.S. president |
| 52% | AIRFORCETWO | 11 | Plane for the U.S. vice president |
| 52% | TERM | 4 | Four years for a U.S president, e.g |
| 51% | TERM | 4 | Four years, for a U.S. president |
| 51% | HONESTABE | 9 | Sobriquet for the sixteenth U.S. President |
| 51% | BUREN | 5 | Part of a U.S. president's name that's Dutch for "neighbors" |
| 51% | MONROE | 6 | Only U.S. President besides Washington for whom a world capital is named |
| 51% | TERM | 4 | Four years for a U.S. president, e.g. |
| 50% | AGE | 3 | 35, minimally, for a U.S. president |
| 50% | USN | 3 | Military branch for former U.S. president Jimmy Carter (Abbr.) |
| 50% | LIMO | 4 | "The Beast" for the U.S. president, for one |
| 50% | TEDDY | 5 | Toy bear named for a U.S. president |
| 49% | LAMAR | 5 | Kendrick who won five Grammys for 2024's "Not Like Us" |