| 100% | IDONTFOLLOW | 11 | "That seems illogical to me" |
| 76% | ISEEIT | 6 | "Yeah, that seems plausible to me" |
| 68% | ITHOUGHTSO | 10 | "That seemed right to me, too" |
| 62% | IMO | 3 | Texter's "It seems to me that...": Abbr. |
| 61% | IDSAYSO | 7 | "Seems that way to me" |
| 60% | WILDEBEEST | 10 | That's gnus to me! |
| 59% | ICANTSEEIT | 10 | "That doesn't seem feasible to me" |
| 57% | DRYER | 5 | Appliance that seems to eat socks |
| 57% | NOR | 3 | "Neither this ___ that seem to work" |
| 56% | SAGA | 4 | Story that seems to go on forever |
| 56% | PARADOX | 7 | A statement that seems to contradict itself |
| 56% | PIT | 3 | Bottomless ___ (hole that seems to never end) |
| 56% | WATCHYOURTONGUE | 15 | “Don’t speak to me that way!” |
| 56% | HOW | 3 | "___ dare you talk to me like that!" |
| 55% | OUIJA | 5 | Mystical board that seems to respond to questions |
| 55% | SARAN | 5 | Wrap that seems to stick to only itself |
| 55% | AURA | 4 | Mystical glow that seems to surround a person |
| 54% | NEMESES | 7 | Foes that seem impossible to beat |
| 54% | SCAM | 4 | Offer that seems too good to be true, probably |
| 54% | EERIE | 5 | Like a portrait that seems to be watching you |
| 54% | ADBLITZ | 7 | Marketing campaign that seems to be everywhere (2 wds.) |
| 54% | TONE | 4 | "Don't talk to me in that ___ of voice!" |
| 54% | TONE | 4 | "Don't speak to me in that ___ of voice!" |
| 54% | TONE | 4 | "Watch your ___!" ("Don't talk to me like that!") |
| 53% | WEIRDRIGHT | 10 | "Does that seem strange to you too?" |
| 53% | ANO | 3 | "I'll take that as ___" ('You don't seem to like the idea") 2 wds. |
| 53% | SHALLI | 6 | "Need me to do that?" |
| 53% | USED | 4 | "Somebody that I ___ to know..." |
| 53% | TON | 3 | Heavy weight that seems to be missing from this puzzle |
| 53% | SCAM | 4 | Telemarketing call that seems too good to be true, probably |