| 100% | LOVE | 4 | ___ potion, magical concoction that the Fairy Godmother brewed for Fiona |
| 33% | POTION | 6 | (4/6) Magical fairy tale concoction that may be brewed in a cauldron (rhymes with "motion") |
| 32% | HOTTEA | 6 | Warm brew that's the British balm for everything |
| 31% | LOOSE | 5 | Like a tooth that's almost ready for the tooth fairy |
| 29% | MIRROR | 6 | (2/6) Magical fairy tale object that may indicate "who the fairest of them all" is |
| 28% | PENTATONIX | 10 | Quintet that won a Grammy for their a cappella version of "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy" |
| 28% | CHARMING | 8 | Prince ___, son of the Fairy Godmother in "Shrek 2" |
| 27% | SPICEDALE | 9 | Special brew for the holidays |
| 27% | WAND | 4 | Magic ___, magical object in the "Shrek" franchise that is used by the Fairy Godmother |
| 27% | BECAUSE | 7 | For the reason that |
| 27% | ZANY | 4 | ___ Brainy, popular children's edutainment store before the millennium that was known for being a magical play place for children |
| 26% | DUST | 4 | Fairy ___, magical substance that you can sprinkle for a touch of enchantment with your "Fairy" Halloween costume |
| 26% | NODS | 4 | Motions that the Christie's auctioneer watches for |
| 26% | FBI | 3 | Org. that the deaf Sue Thomas worked for |
| 26% | LOVEPOTION | 10 | Magical brew that causes amorous feelings |
| 26% | DARKALES | 8 | Brews that Belgium is famous for |
| 26% | CAMERACREW | 10 | Those who shoot for the stars? |
| 26% | ALS | 3 | Disorder that the Ice Bucket Challenge benefited, for short |
| 26% | GIANTLEAP | 9 | Something that the Apollo 11 Commander made for mankind |
| 26% | CREW | 4 | The Brew ___ (nickname for the Milwaukee Brewers) |
| 25% | ASSAMTEA | 8 | Brew that originates near the Brahmaputra River |
| 25% | AND | 3 | The word that ampersands are used for |
| 25% | EVENIF | 6 | Allowing for the possibility that |
| 25% | ITSAMIRACLE | 11 | “Thank the gods for that!” |
| 25% | ALS | 3 | Disease that the Ice Bucket Challenge raises awareness for: Abbr. |
| 25% | BEAN | 4 | Magical item for Jack in a fairy tale |
| 25% | SUGARPLUM | 9 | Fairy that dances in Tchaikovsky's The Nutcracker |
| 25% | PLANET | 6 | The Daily __, newspaper that Clark Kent works for |
| 25% | CALCIUM | 7 | The mineral that is important for building bones |
| 25% | LOOSE | 5 | Almost ready for the tooth fairy |