| 100% | ISHE | 4 | “This --” (telephone response) |
| 81% | ITIS | 4 | Response to "Can this be?" |
| 81% | HAPPYFACE | 9 | Response to solving this puzzle |
| 81% | NOTME | 5 | Response to "Who broke this?!" |
| 79% | IDO | 3 | "Who wants this?" response |
| 77% | TRYME | 5 | Response to "You won't believe this!" |
| 77% | TRYME | 5 | Response to "You'll never believe this!" |
| 77% | TRYME | 5 | Response to "You won't believe this" |
| 75% | ONIT | 4 | Response to "Can you take care of this?" |
| 75% | MINE | 4 | Possible response to "Whose is this?" |
| 73% | TRYME | 5 | Response to "You won't believe this" (2 wds.) |
| 73% | SCORE | 5 | Response to "Look at this free thing I got!" |
| 72% | AMIEVER | 7 | Enthusiastic response to "You ready for this?" |
| 72% | BAHHOMBURG | 10 | Hat-hater's response to this puzzle? |
| 72% | TRYITON | 7 | "I wonder if this will fit" response |
| 72% | LURES | 5 | Anglers hope these will bring biting responses |
| 71% | TMI | 3 | Response to oversharing found in this puzzle's starred answers |
| 71% | YES | 3 | Response to Santa's "Have you been good this year?" |
| 70% | IHAVENOIDEA | 11 | One's initial response to this clue, perhaps |
| 70% | YES | 3 | Wry response to a this-or-that question |
| 70% | YES | 3 | Hoped-for response to “Is this your card?” |
| 69% | IAM | 3 | Response to “You sure you want to go through with this?” |
| 68% | IBROKEIT | 8 | Guilty response to "Why doesn't this work anymore?" |
| 68% | IDID | 4 | Surprised response to “You already told me this story” |
| 67% | IDO | 3 | Response to "Do you take this man as your...," generally: 2 wds. |
| 66% | HOWSOON | 7 | Question in response to "I need this in a hurry" |
| 66% | NOTATALL | 8 | Polite response to "Would this be an imposition?": 3 wds. |
| 66% | TRYME | 5 | Possible response to "You're not going to believe this" |
| 60% | LOL | 3 | Response to a funny text, and a hint to this puzzle's five longest answers |
| 60% | OKDEAR | 6 | Honey-do-this response |