| 100% | EERIE | 5 | Bizarre and scary |
| 63% | EERIE | 5 | Weird and scary |
| 63% | JARRING | 7 | Unexpected and scary |
| 63% | EERIE | 5 | Strange and scary |
| 60% | KAFKAESQUE | 10 | Bizarre and alienating |
| 60% | EERIE | 5 | Bizarre and unreal |
| 60% | WEIRD | 5 | Bizarre and uncanny |
| 59% | ANTIC | 5 | Bizarre and ludicrous action |
| 56% | EERIEST | 7 | Most weird and scary |
| 54% | EERIE | 5 | Scary and strange |
| 53% | HALLOWEEN | 9 | Holiday involving pumpkins and scary costumes |
| 52% | POSH | 4 | Bandmate of Sporty, Ginger, Baby, and Scary |
| 52% | FARIS | 5 | The House Bunny and Scary Movie actress |
| 52% | POSH | 4 | Bandmate of Baby, Ginger, Sporty, and Scary |
| 51% | MACABRE | 7 | Gruesome and scary as in a ghostly tale |
| 50% | SPICEGIRLS | 10 | Scary, Baby, Ginger, Posh and Sporty |
| 49% | PUMPKIN | 7 | Fruit used for pies and scary jack-o'-lanterns |
| 47% | ABSURDISM | 9 | Using bizarre, illogical and incoherent settings |
| 46% | SPORTY | 6 | Bandmate of Ginger, Scary, Posh and Baby |
| 45% | ALLBARK | 7 | __ and no bite; not as scary as it looks |
| 45% | ANIME | 5 | Genre for Naruto and JoJo's Bizarre Adventure |
| 45% | MEL | 3 | First name of Scary Spice and Sporty Spice |
| 45% | POSHSPICE | 9 | Bandmate of Baby, Scary and Sporty; now Beckham |
| 45% | SPICE | 5 | Word with Scary, Sporty, Ginger, Baby, and Posh |
| 42% | DALI | 4 | Spanish surrealist painter, who often created striking and bizarre images |
| 42% | OFFTHEWALL | 10 | Bizarre, and what the ends of 16-, 22-, 37-, and 49-Across are when redecorating |
| 40% | SHEILAE | 7 | "The Glamorous Life" and "A Love Bizarre" singer and percussionist: 2 wds. |
| 34% | OTERI | 5 | Cheri who acted in “Inspector Gadget” and “Scary Movie” |
| 34% | BREATHE | 7 | 1996 song by The Prodigy that has a scary music video featuring aural and psychological phenomena |
| 34% | ORWORSE | 7 | "...and that's not even the scariest possibility!" |