| 100% | TORTONI | 7 | Dessert topped with crumbled macaroons |
| 93% | TORTONI | 7 | Italian dessert topped with crumbled macaroons |
| 75% | TORTONI | 7 | Dessert garnished with crumbled macaroons |
| 56% | BACONDONUTS | 11 | Desserts topped with maple syrup |
| 56% | DIRTPIES | 8 | Desserts topped with gummy worms |
| 54% | BAKLAVA | 7 | Flaky dessert topped with syrup |
| 53% | TORTONI | 7 | Biscuit __, ice cream with crumbled macaroons |
| 53% | APPLEPIEALAMODE | 15 | Diner dessert topped with a scoop |
| 52% | PAVLOVA | 7 | Meringue dessert topped with cream and fruit |
| 50% | OREO | 4 | Crumbled dessert topping |
| 49% | OREOPIE | 7 | Dessert with crumbled cookies |
| 48% | CREMEBRULEE | 11 | Dessert with a caramelized top |
| 47% | OREOPIE | 7 | Dessert with a crumbled, chocolaty crust |
| 46% | COFFEECAKE | 10 | Dessert often topped with streusel |
| 46% | OREO | 4 | ___ Cone (Good Humor treat with crumbled cookie pieces on top) |
| 45% | FLAN | 4 | Dessert often topped with caramel sauce |
| 45% | CHEESECAKE | 10 | Dessert often topped with cherry sauce |
| 45% | SUNDAE | 6 | Dessert often topped with hot fudge |
| 44% | CARROTCAKE | 10 | Dessert often topped with cream cheese frosting |
| 44% | COBBLER | 7 | Fruit __, baked dessert with scone/biscuit topping |
| 44% | TARTS | 5 | Pie-like desserts with no top crusts |
| 44% | CARROTCAKE | 10 | Dessert often topped with cream cheese (1990-93) |
| 43% | SPLIT | 5 | Banana ___, ice-cream dessert with cherries on top |
| 43% | ICECREAMSUNDAES | 15 | Desserts often topped with whipped cream and maraschino cherries |
| 43% | CRISP | 5 | Apple ___, dessert with a crumbly top and baked apples |
| 42% | LEMONPIE | 8 | Tangy dessert often topped with meringue |
| 41% | CHEESECAKE | 10 | Dessert that's often topped with berries |
| 40% | CAKE | 4 | Dessert that may be topped with two brides |
| 40% | APPLEPIE | 8 | Dessert that may be topped with cheddar cheese |
| 39% | CREAM | 5 | Dessert topping |