| 100% | TORTONI | 7 | Ice cream with an Italian name |
| 62% | STILETTO | 8 | Weapon with an Italian name |
| 58% | STILETTO | 8 | Spiky high heel, or a knife with an Italian name |
| 58% | HAAGEN | 6 | Half of an ice cream brand with a fake Danish name |
| 55% | GELATO | 6 | An Italian frozen treat similar to ice cream |
| 55% | CASSATA | 7 | Italian ice cream with candied fruit and nuts |
| 55% | HAAGENDAZS | 10 | Ice cream company with a pseudo-Scandinavian name |
| 55% | ALAMODE | 7 | Served with an ice cream portion |
| 54% | BOLOGNA | 7 | An Italian city that shares its name with sausage |
| 51% | HALO | 4 | ___ Top (ice cream brand with an angelic name) |
| 50% | HAAGENDAZS | 10 | New York City-born ice cream brand with a Danish-sounding name |
| 50% | HALO | 4 | ___ Top (ice cream brand with an "angelic" name) |
| 50% | BEN | 3 | Name on an ice cream carton |
| 50% | REMEMBERTHEALAMODE | 18 | Name for an ice cream shop? |
| 48% | SUNDAE | 6 | Ice cream with toppings |
| 46% | CUSTARD | 7 | Ice cream with added egg yolk |
| 46% | ROCKYROAD | 9 | Ice cream with chocolate, almonds, and marshmallow |
| 45% | EDY | 3 | Ice cream name |
| 45% | HAAGEN | 6 | Part of an ice cream brand's pseudo-Scandinavian name |
| 45% | TORTONI | 7 | Biscuit __, ice cream with crumbled macaroons |
| 45% | DONDURMA | 8 | Turkish "freezing" ice cream with salep |
| 45% | FRUTTI | 6 | Tutti __, ice cream with candied produce |
| 45% | KAFFIR | 6 | Lime with an Arabic first name |
| 44% | BEN | 3 | Other half of an ice cream team, with Jerry |
| 44% | ROCKYROAD | 9 | Chocolate ice cream with nuts and marshmallow |
| 44% | SUNDAES | 7 | Ice cream desserts with toppings |
| 44% | GELATI | 6 | Ice cream made with eggs |
| 44% | BIRTHDAYCAKE | 12 | Ice cream flavor with sprinkles |
| 44% | SUNDAE | 6 | Ice cream treat with toppings |
| 44% | CAKEBATTER | 10 | Ice cream flavor with sprinkles |