| 100% | NOGG | 4 | Egg___, a popular drink around Christmas time |
| 53% | NOG | 3 | Egg___(Creamy beverage which is popular around Christmas time) |
| 51% | NOGG | 4 | Egg ___, popular Christmas drink |
| 50% | NOG | 3 | Egg___, a popular festive drink |
| 45% | LEMONADE | 8 | A popular drink |
| 42% | EGGNOG | 6 | As a rule, a Christmas time drink |
| 42% | ADE | 3 | "Lemon" suffix for a popular drink |
| 41% | NOG | 3 | Eggy drink that's popular around Christmas |
| 41% | WASSAIL | 7 | Hot, mulled punch traditionally drunk around Christmas |
| 41% | WONDERFUL | 9 | "It's the Most ___ Time of the Year," a hugely popular Christmas song by Andy Williams |
| 41% | PONG | 4 | Last word in a popular drinking game |
| 40% | TEA | 3 | A popular beverage best drank hot |
| 40% | ADE | 3 | Suffix, when added with lemon, makes a popular drink |
| 39% | SIP | 3 | Drink just a little at a time |
| 39% | ROE | 3 | Eggs rarely eaten one at a time |
| 39% | NOG | 3 | Christmas egg drink |
| 39% | NENE | 4 | Maui or Hawaii bird that lays eggs around Christmas time |
| 39% | NOG | 3 | Creamy egg beverage that is popular around Christmas |
| 39% | SCREW | 5 | It's followed by "driver" to mean a popular drink |
| 39% | FAITHFUL | 8 | A popular Christmas carol, O Come, All Ye __ |
| 39% | CUSTARD | 7 | Popular Christmas time dessert |
| 38% | AGED | 4 | Around a long time |
| 38% | REINDEER | 8 | Common Christmas time name for a caribou |
| 38% | OLD | 3 | Having been around for a long time |
| 37% | NOG | 3 | Egg___, a drink also called egg milk punch |
| 37% | REDFIR | 6 | North American coniferous evergreen; a popular Christmas tree |
| 37% | KATS | 4 | Swat ___, a popular cartoon revolving around two felines |
| 37% | TONIC | 5 | Gin's partner in a popular mixed drink |
| 37% | NOG | 3 | Christmas drink that includes egg yolks |
| 37% | EASTER | 6 | Popular time for an egg roll |