| 100% | LETTERMAN | 9 | Former late-night host with a "Stupid Pet Tricks" bit |
| 57% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host Jay with a car show on CNBC |
| 47% | CONAN | 5 | Late-night host with a gag involving an orange blimp |
| 46% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host who wrote the autobiography "Leading With My Chin" |
| 45% | LENO | 4 | Former late night TV host |
| 45% | OBRIEN | 6 | Former late night TV host |
| 45% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host who has a voice cameo in "Cars" as Jay Limo |
| 44% | CONAN | 5 | Late-night show with a redheaded host |
| 44% | JAYLENO | 7 | Former late-night TV host who co-wrote the book “Leading with My Chin” |
| 42% | JOEROGAN | 8 | Former Fear Factor host with a popular podcast |
| 41% | RICKILAKE | 9 | Former talk show host with a "watery" name: 2 wds. |
| 41% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host |
| 41% | LENO | 4 | Late-night host Jay with a recurring role in "Last Man Standing" |
| 40% | NYE | 3 | Former PBS host with a bow tie |
| 40% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host Jay |
| 40% | JAY | 3 | Former late-night host Leno |
| 40% | CRAIG | 5 | Former late-night host Ferguson |
| 40% | CONAN | 5 | Former late-night host O'Brien |
| 39% | JAYLENO | 7 | Former TV host with a distinct chin, loves cars |
| 39% | CRAIG | 5 | Former late-night host Kilborn or Ferguson |
| 39% | SNYDER | 6 | Former late-night TV host |
| 39% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night TV host |
| 39% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night TV host Jay |
| 38% | ARSENIO | 7 | Former late-night talk show host Hall |
| 38% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night talk show host Jay |
| 37% | ARSENIO | 7 | Former late-night host Hall who won "Celebrity Apprentice" in 2012 |
| 37% | LENO | 4 | Former late-night host known for "Jaywalking" and "Iron Jay" segments |
| 37% | SINGH | 5 | Lilly ___, former late-night talk show host |
| 37% | LENO | 4 | Late-night host who competed with Letterman |
| 37% | LENO | 4 | Late night host |