| 100% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who plays baseball in the New York Mets' farm system |
| 44% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who plays Minor League baseball |
| 43% | ALOU | 4 | Moises ___, former MLB outfielder who last played for the New York Mets before retiring in 2009 |
| 39% | ELI | 3 | Quarterback Manning who played 16 seasons for the New York Giants |
| 38% | SHEA | 4 | Former New York stadium where the Mets played |
| 37% | GIL | 3 | Hodges in the New York Mets Hall of Fame |
| 36% | TEBOW | 5 | Quarterback Tim who played for the Broncos and Jets |
| 35% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who was the first sophomore to win the Heisman Trophy |
| 34% | TEBOW | 5 | Quarterback Tim who signed with the Eagles in April |
| 34% | GILHODGES | 9 | World Series-winning manager of the 1969 New York Mets who was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2022 (2 wds.) |
| 34% | ROSE | 4 | Pete ___, former baseball player who is the all-time MLB leader in hits and number of games played |
| 34% | SHEA | 4 | Former home of the New York Mets |
| 33% | HAYLEYATWELL | 12 | Actress who plays Grace in the new "Mission: Impossible" movie: 2 wds. |
| 33% | EZRA | 4 | Actor Miller who plays Flash in the new DC films |
| 33% | MOOKIEWILSON | 12 | Outfielder for the 1986 New York Mets who batted into the so-called "Buckner play": 2 wds. |
| 33% | JANEKRAKOWSKI | 13 | "Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt" actress who plays the recent widow of a New York Jets fan in Season 10 of "Curb Your Enthusiasm" (2 wds.) |
| 33% | KURTRUSSELL | 11 | "Escape from New York" actor who played Elvis Presley in the TV film "Elvis" and an Elvis impersonator in "3000 Miles to Graceland" (2 wds.) |
| 33% | PETEALONSO | 10 | New York Mets first baseman who won the 2021 Home Run Derby (2 wds.) |
| 33% | MIKE | 4 | Former NY Mets' legendary catcher Piazza who was nicknamed "The Pizza Man" and was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2016 |
| 32% | METS | 4 | New York baseball team featured in the documentary "Doc & Darryl" |
| 32% | JACOBDEGROM | 11 | New York Mets pitcher who won the 2018 National League Cy Young Award (2 wds.) |
| 32% | DONNCLENDENON | 13 | New York Mets first baseman who was MVP of the 1969 World Series (2 wds.) |
| 32% | LOU | 3 | ___ Gehrig, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Columbia University |
| 32% | RED | 3 | ___ Rolfe, former baseball player for the New York Yankees who attended Dartmouth College |
| 32% | KATZ | 4 | Eponym of the New York City deli featured in "When Harry Met Sally ..." |
| 32% | SHEA | 4 | New York stadium where the Jets and Mets used to play |
| 32% | JOE | 3 | Former quarterback Namath who tossed the coin in Super Bowl XLVIII |
| 32% | PEYTONMANNING | 13 | Former NFL quarterback who did not play in 2011 due to multiple surgeries and won the Comeback Player of the Year in 2012: 2 wds. |
| 32% | TOMMYLEEJONES | 13 | Actor who played baseball's Ty Cobb in the 1994 biopic "Cobb": 3 wds. |
| 32% | COHEN | 5 | Billionaire Steve who owns the New York Mets |