| 100% | TEBOW | 5 | Tim ___, American baseball outfielder |
| 59% | BUDDY | 5 | ___ Bell, American baseball manager who is the son of former baseball outfielder Gus Bell |
| 52% | MITT | 4 | Baseball outfielder's glove |
| 52% | LOU | 3 | American baseball's ___ Gehrig |
| 52% | EMIL | 4 | American baseball player ___ Brown |
| 51% | OTT | 3 | American baseball legend, Melvin Thomas ___ |
| 49% | LOU | 3 | Former baseball outfielder Piniella |
| 47% | RYAN | 4 | American baseball player ___ Howard nicknamed the "Big Piece" |
| 46% | OREL | 4 | ___ Leonard Hershiser IV, former American baseball pitcher |
| 45% | KEEFE | 5 | Baseball Hall-of-Famer Tim |
| 45% | WILLIE | 6 | American baseball player ___ Mays nicknamed the "The Say Hey Kid" |
| 44% | TUG | 3 | Tim McGraw's baseball-playing dad |
| 43% | RAINES | 6 | Tim ___, 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame inductee |
| 43% | OREL | 4 | Hershiser, American former baseball pitcher |
| 42% | YELICH | 6 | Christian ___, baseball outfielder who has won two Silver Slugger Awards |
| 42% | ENOS | 4 | Outfielder Slaughter in the Baseball Hall of Fame |
| 42% | LOU | 3 | Outfielder Brock in the Baseball Hall of Fame |
| 42% | TEBOW | 5 | Tim who played pro football and pro baseball |
| 42% | OTT | 3 | American professional baseball player nicknamed "Master Melvin" Mel ___ |
| 42% | LEAGUE | 6 | National or American, in professional baseball |
| 41% | LESTER | 6 | Jon ___, American baseball player who announced his retirement in January 2022 |
| 41% | LIE | 3 | Tim Roth's American crime drama series "___ to Me" |
| 40% | TUG | 3 | Singer Tim McGraw's baseball-playing dad |
| 39% | REDS | 4 | Baseball team that plays at the Great American Ball Park |
| 39% | PETE | 4 | American former professional baseball player who played in MLB, ___ Rose |
| 39% | MARUCCI | 7 | American sports equipment manufacturing company that focuses on baseball equipment |
| 39% | MOISES | 6 | ___ Alou, baseball outfielder who is the son of former baseball outfielder Felipe Alou |
| 39% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who plays Minor League baseball |
| 39% | ELFMAN | 6 | Danny, American composer on Tim Burton's movies |
| 39% | COUCH | 5 | Tim ___, American football player who set a number of national high school records |