| 100% | TEBOW | 5 | Quarterback Tim who played for the Broncos and Jets |
| 51% | ELI | 3 | Quarterback Manning who played for the Giants |
| 50% | GINO | 4 | ___ Torretta, who played quarterback for the University of Miami and won the Heisman Trophy in 1992 |
| 47% | NOMO | 4 | Pitcher who played for the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Kintetsu Buffaloes |
| 47% | NASH | 4 | Former NBA star Steve who played for the Suns, Mavericks, and Lakers |
| 47% | BOWA | 4 | Larry who played for and managed the Phillies |
| 47% | JOHNELWAY | 9 | Denver Broncos quarterback who played minor league baseball for the Yankees: 2 wds. |
| 47% | TEBOW | 5 | Former quarterback Tim who plays baseball in the New York Mets' farm system |
| 46% | SAL | 3 | Third baseman Bando who played for the A's in the 1960s and 1970s |
| 46% | RYAN | 4 | ___ Russell, queer footballer who played for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2016 and 2017 |
| 46% | ORR | 3 | Ice hockey legend Bobby ___ who played for the Boston Bruins and Chicago Black Hawks |
| 46% | DEION | 5 | Sanders who played for both the Reds and the Redskins |
| 46% | BROOKE | 6 | Zinzan ___, former New Zealand rugby player who played for the All Blacks and Auckland Blues |
| 46% | CHO | 3 | Chang who plays for the Ravenclaw Quidditch team and kisses Harry Potter under the mistletoe |
| 46% | BARTSTARR | 9 | Super Bowl I and II champion quarterback who played for the University of Alabama (2 wds.) |
| 45% | GREGMADDUX | 10 | Legendary pitcher nicknamed "Mad Dog," who played for the Atlanta Braves and the Chicago Cubs: 2 wds |
| 45% | MARINO | 6 | Hall of Fame quarterback Dan who played for the Miami Dolphins |
| 45% | ELI | 3 | Quarterback Manning who played 16 seasons for the New York Giants |
| 44% | TJWARD | 6 | Safety drafted by the Browns in 2010 who played for the Broncos in 2014-17 and is god-brother to Maurice Jones-Drew |
| 43% | SHOHEIOHTANI | 12 | Pitcher and outfielder who plays for the Los Angeles Angels (2 wds.) |
| 43% | CLETE | 5 | Boyer who played third base for the Yankees in the '50s and '60s |
| 43% | JOHNRANDLE | 10 | Defensive tackle who played for the Minnesota Vikings and Seattle Seahawks and is one of the greatest pass rushers ever: 2 wds. |
| 42% | TROY | 4 | Aikman who played for the Cowboys |
| 42% | EVAN | 4 | Longoria who played for the Rays |
| 42% | ERNIEBANKS | 10 | Negro Leaguer who played first base and shortstop for the Cubs (1953-1971): 2 wds. |
| 41% | OREE | 4 | Willie who played for the Boston Bruins |
| 41% | ODOM | 4 | Lamar who played for the 59-Across |
| 41% | RIK | 3 | Smits who played for the Indiana Pacers |
| 41% | WAYNE | 5 | ___ Rooney, English footballer who played for DC United in MLS and was one of the highest paid MLS players in 2019 |
| 41% | BASTIAN | 7 | ___ Schweinsteiger, German footballer who played for Chicago Fire in MLS and was one of the highest paid MLS players in 2019 |