| 100% | NOSETOTAIL | 10 | Like cooking that goes whole hog? |
| 48% | EATATON | 7 | Go whole hog on Thanksgiving |
| 44% | TIED | 4 | Like games that go into overtime |
| 43% | ORAL | 4 | Like thermometers that go into the mouth |
| 42% | EERIE | 5 | Like things that go bump in the night |
| 42% | ALEAD | 5 | “Well, that went over like ___ balloon” |
| 41% | ATON | 4 | "Well, that went over like __ of bricks!" |
| 40% | RARE | 4 | Like steak that's barely cooked |
| 40% | SOUR | 4 | Like milk that's gone bad |
| 40% | STALE | 5 | Like bread that's gone bad |
| 40% | BAD | 3 | Like milk that's gone sour |
| 40% | STU | 3 | Apt name for a cook that sounds like "Stew" |
| 40% | PLANTAIN | 8 | Cooking vegetable that looks like a banana |
| 40% | GNAWING | 7 | Like doubts that won't go away |
| 40% | MARBLED | 7 | Like steak that's going to sizzle |
| 40% | GRISLY | 6 | Like details that make you go "Eww!" |
| 40% | RELIT | 5 | Like a cigarette that's gone out |
| 40% | EERIE | 5 | Like coincidences that make you go "hmm" |
| 39% | BLANCH | 6 | Cooking verb that sounds like a Golden Girl |
| 39% | FIRM | 4 | Like pasta that's been cooked al dente |
| 39% | RAW | 3 | Like cranberries that haven't been cooked yet |
| 39% | RARE | 4 | Like steak that's cooked less than medium |
| 39% | RELIT | 5 | Like a candle that's gone out, maybe |
| 39% | EERIE | 5 | Like a coincidence that makes you go "Hmm ..." |
| 39% | FUELLED | 7 | Like a Bentley that's ready to go |
| 39% | CLAPPERS | 8 | Going like the __, idiom that refers to bells |
| 39% | DOA | 3 | Like an idea that’s going nowhere, informally |
| 39% | POOF | 4 | [Just like that, it's gone!] |
| 38% | RARE | 4 | Like steak that's been cooked less than "medium" |
| 38% | RARE | 4 | Like a steak that's not cooked very much |