| 100% | DONDRAPER | 9 | Mad Men character who made the finale's Coke ad |
| 37% | DON | 3 | Draper who's the main character of "Mad Men" |
| 37% | DON | 3 | Draper who's the main character on "Mad Men" |
| 37% | FAUST | 5 | Goethe character who makes a pact with the devil |
| 36% | FAUST | 5 | Classic literary character who makes a deal with the devil |
| 36% | DONDRAPER | 9 | The Mad Men character played by Jon Hamm |
| 35% | GAGARIN | 7 | Yuri —, Soviet cosmonaut who made the first manned space flight in 1961 |
| 35% | PETE | 4 | "Mad Men" character Campbell who's married to Trudy |
| 34% | ALICE | 5 | Character who has tea with the Mad Hatter and the Cheshire Cat |
| 32% | JIMHENSON | 9 | The man who created the Muppets characters |
| 32% | SMURF | 5 | Character who's blue in the face? |
| 32% | OPHELIA | 7 | Character who went mad in Shakespeare's Hamlet |
| 32% | STORM | 5 | "X-Men" character who can control the weather |
| 32% | ART | 3 | ___ Vandelay, recurring fake "Seinfeld" character who appears as a real judge in the series finale |
| 31% | ALICE | 5 | Character who's told "We're all mad here" |
| 31% | FLO | 3 | Character who's appeared in over 100 Progressive ads |
| 31% | OLAF | 4 | "Frozen" character who's made of snow |
| 31% | SABLE | 5 | Silver ___, character who is one of Spider-Man's love interests in the "What If?" comics |
| 31% | AHAB | 4 | Character who nails a doubloon to the Pequod's mast |
| 31% | KANE | 4 | Film title character who says, "If the headline is big enough, it makes the news big enough" |
| 30% | IGOR | 4 | Character who’s “on chains” in the lyrics of “Monster Mash” |
| 30% | TAILORS | 7 | People who make men's clothing such as suits |
| 30% | IAGO | 4 | Literary character who says "Cassio's a proper man" |
| 30% | PRIVATEJETSON | 13 | Space Age cartoon character who's joined the army? |
| 30% | OFFRED | 6 | Chief character who narrates The Handmaid's Tale |
| 30% | TIN | 3 | The ___ Man (character made from a metal) |
| 30% | MRBIRTHDAYS | 11 | Man who's annually in the doghouse? |
| 30% | GLENN | 5 | Senator who made the rounds |
| 30% | ALEWIFE | 7 | Woman who makes the rounds? |
| 30% | CLOSER | 6 | One who makes the sale |