| 100% | THAT | 4 | Madonna's "Who's ___ Girl" |
| 81% | DAVIDFINCHER | 12 | "Gone Girl" director who also directed the music video for Madonna's "Vogue": 2 wds. |
| 78% | THAT | 4 | Who's ___ girl? |
| 75% | TRUEBLUE | 8 | Madonna album in between “Like a Virgin” and “Who’s That Girl” |
| 72% | SIS | 3 | Girl who's a sib |
| 71% | DEB | 3 | Girl who's having a ball |
| 69% | MISSINFORMATION | 15 | Girl who's got her facts wrong? |
| 68% | ADELINE | 7 | Girl who's "the flower of my heart" |
| 66% | CADETTE | 7 | Girl Scout who's 12 to 14 years old |
| 66% | SEANPENN | 8 | Actor who was Madonna's first husband |
| 66% | LISA | 4 | "The Simpsons" girl who's an environmentalist |
| 66% | OPHELIA | 7 | Girl who drowns in Shakespeare's Hamlet |
| 66% | MARY | 4 | Nursery rhyme girl who's "quite contrary" |
| 64% | IDA | 3 | Song girl who's "sweet as apple cider" |
| 64% | CANDICE | 7 | Girl's name and TikTok joke Who is … |
| 63% | THAT | 4 | "Who's ___ girl?" |
| 63% | IDA | 3 | Girl who's "sweet as apple cider," per an old song |
| 63% | LIESL | 5 | Von Trapp girl who's "sixteen going on seventeen" |
| 63% | BARB | 4 | Girl who goes missing in Netflix's "Stranger Things" |
| 63% | VERONICA | 8 | Mean girl who's frenemies with Betty in Riverdale |
| 63% | ALICE | 5 | Girl who went to Wonderland in Carroll's books |
| 63% | NEST | 4 | "The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's ___" |
| 61% | HEIDI | 5 | Girl of children's literature who lives in the Alps |
| 61% | IPANEMA | 7 | Whence a girl who's "like a samba," in song |
| 61% | HERMIONE | 8 | Hogwarts girl who's book-smart and a loyal friend |
| 61% | MOON | 4 | Kelly Barnhill children's book "The Girl Who Drank the __" |
| 61% | LEA | 3 | Actress Michele who's starring in "Funny Girl" on Broadway |
| 61% | MILLI | 5 | __ Vanilli, duo who "sang" Girl You Know It's True |
| 61% | BELL | 4 | Kristen who narrates HBO Max's "Gossip Girl" |
| 60% | CODE | 4 | Girls Who ___ |